— 223 —
intends from now on to hold the vacation courses also essentially in Berlin, but hopes that in other centres too fellow-adherents with scientific training will join together to hold such courses, whether in the form of vacation courses, which, intended for a certain number of hearers, naturally, in consequence of their being crowded into few days, act more as a stimulus than as direct instruction; or in the form of Palestine courses distributed over the semester, which, though they reckon with a small number of students, make possible a more intensive penetration of the subject, and, especially when they are held in seminar form and are combined with papers and written elaborations by the participants, are quite extraordinarily effective for intensive Palestine propaganda. In this connexion it especially comes into account that, for the holding of current Palestine courses, ultimately even a force endowed with a talent for teaching suffices — one who has hitherto immersed himself but little in the Palestine questions, but who, in intercourse with the students and through the preparations for the course itself, gradually penetrates more deeply into the subject.
Only through such courses are we able to rear a stock of people who, equipped with the necessary material of positive knowledge, are at any time able to oppose vigorously the still frequent objections concerning the unsuitability of Palestine for the centralization of the Jews. Our opponents can only be brought to silence by our being able to represent them as ignorant. So long as one cannot show oneself to be a connoisseur of the relevant conditions, opinion stands against opinion, and one cannot demand of the opponent that he give up his own in favour of ours. But if he perceives that every one of his assertions is at once refuted by facts, he will soon lose the desire for further discussions and become more reserved; indeed, in many cases he will let himself be convinced of a better view.
Our Palestine library also has undergone a considerable increase through the purchase both of individual valuable works and especially of the Palestine library left by Mr. Bambus.
Finally, mention must yet be made of the endeavour to found, in connexion with the Jewish Publishing House, an Orient Publishing House, which is to occupy itself with the issue of special literature relating to the Orient. Above all,
