— 30 —
Despite the separation of Church and State in its own country, and despite the persecution of the congregations, it appears nevertheless that here they will not renounce the latter, to whom France in fact owes its influence in Syria and Palestine.
For a long time already, despite the laws hostile to the Church, France has been occupied with the question of the so-called French protectorate in the Levant (as in China). We know quite precisely that even in the question of the patriarchate highly placed Roman prelates were, and still are, active in favour of France. In order to make an end of all intrigues, Pius X has taken from France — which possesses the right of nomination for the patriarchal see — that right for the present vacancy, and will himself determine the Patriarch.
In France the opinion is widely held that Syria and Palestine are at bottom French property. But the Orient is after all neither an ecclesiastical nor a political domain of France. What is to be understood by the so-called traditional protectorate, again so gladly emphasized of late by the French Government? No one can fail to recognize the truly grand services of Catholic France to the foreign missions. But the former practically general French protectorate has been limited, in law and in fact, by every Power itself exercising the protectorship over the members of its own nationality, no matter to what confession they belong. One has thus to distinguish in Palestine a threefold kind of protectorate:
-
the right of protection of each individual Christian Power over the subjects of its nationality and their mission works, which is fixed by international treaties;
-
the right of protection over the individual ecclesiastical institutes of the Holy Land, e.g. the Patriarchate as such and the Custody of the Holy Land, ecclesiastical establishments which are subordinated to the Propaganda;
-
the right of protection over the native Christians, who as natives are subjects of the Turkish Sultan.
Over the two last-named categories France has now claimed a protectorate down to the most recent time, and it is with reference to this that one speaks of a so-called traditional protectorate of France.
As regards the ecclesiastical institutions named under No. 2, it was for Rome an imperative need that, so long as the Holy See does not possess, through a nunciature in Constantinople and a Turkish envoy at the Vatican, a regulated diplomatic intercourse for the protection of the rights and freedom of the Church in the Holy Land, one among the Christian Powers should assume the obligation of mediating, in cases arising, the intercourse between the Holy See and the Ottoman Government, above all when general Catholic questions are concerned which are withdrawn from the sphere of each single one of the European Powers; in such questions the Holy See has in fact in former times addressed itself to the French authorities, while in the last decades French help has in many cases obtruded itself, and there, where an energetic intervention had to be expected, has — out of affection for the schismatic ally Russia — proved inactive and insignificant, indeed often even dangerous. The Holy See is not bound to such a protection by France, and could in each individual case also request another Christian Power for mediations with
