— 24 —
essential contradiction if we define a colony as the joint settling-down of a part of a people in a territory situated outside the proper dwelling, culture, or power sphere of the people as a whole, whether for reasons which hold good only in this part of the people, or for such as are decisive for the people as a whole, provided only that the original national character of the settlement is preserved. — We must point out that this definition corresponds exactly to none of the definitions given by the theorists of colonization, which appeared to us either too narrow or too wide; while we believe that nothing stands in the way of the validity of our definition above, because, without undertaking a limitation which would leave us helpless in face of certain undoubtedly colonial phenomena, it yet does not go so far as to label as "colonies" settlements which have already become completely independent, in the national respect also — which would be to do violence to the facts. Among the first-named phenomena would, in our opinion, be reckoned, for example, the German colonies in the Magyar and Slav territories of Austria-Hungary; whereas, in contrast to this, it is hardly admissible today still to speak of North America as an English colony, and it is quite certainly inadmissible to call India, say, a British colony — which the Englishman himself, indeed, never does, who always distinguishes: India, the colonies and other British possessions. Moreover it does not seem to us sufficient to speak of a colony as a "settlement . . ." unless the lasting and in some measure systematic character of this settlement is emphasized at the same time, as is suitably done by the word "settling-down." Further, a settlement whose population has entirely and altogether lost the more intimate connection with the parent people and has been absorbed in the foreign people will no longer be able to be designated a colony, so that it is necessary to regard the preservation of the original nationality of the colonists as an indispensable characteristic. On the motives, too, for the erection of the settlement in the foreign land the definition of the colony must contain something, because it might perhaps appear to many that the heterogeneity of the reasons — whether, for example, a smaller number of members of the people emigrate on their own initiative and found a
