Altneuland · Vol. III, No. 1 · January 1906
14printed page
scan 14 of 32
Facsimile · scan 14 of 32
Scan of p. 14
English · AI translation, checked against the German

— 14 —

But only then will they come to love the soil they have leased, when they are also in a position to lay out plantations upon it. For it is these that, under the subtropical conditions of Palestine, first give a farm its right foothold. They afford the colonist and the tenant the possibility of attaining a firmer prosperity. For this, however, the leases concluded with the tenant would have to be of longer duration, which should hardly be set at under 25 years.

The experiment at the Lake of Tiberias failed, on the one hand, for the reasons set forth above; on the other, in consequence of the unfavourable climate of the district and the insufficient guarantees on the part of the owner, who simply drove the tenants out when they could not at once answer his expectations of increased profit — reasons, unfortunately, which we had indeed foreseen in our yearly survey of 1905.

The tenant question gains heightened interest for us, as we have already mentioned above, from the further fact that we have at present to concern ourselves with the question of the utilization of the lands at Dalaika Sahu and Hattîn, which belong to the National Fund. The demand of our Russian fellow-partisans that these lands be leased only to Jews is a fully justified one, and one we share.**) But the question arises out of what sums the buildings absolutely required for the tenants are to be erected. It is hardly to be assumed that our tenants will dispose of means which will permit them not only the purchase of working cattle, implements, and seed, together with the defraying of their existence up to the first harvest, but also the building of houses, stables, and yards. We have seen what failure the "provisional" installations of tenants by the JCA have yielded, and have also defined the chief causes of this failure. Shall we now, when we approach the practical execution of our ideas, fall into the same error which we castigated in the JCA? Shall our tenants too, after 1–2 years of provisional tenancy, after the loss of not inconsiderable material sacrifices, quit the land in embitterment?


**) The leasing of the lands of the National Fund for the current year 1905/06 was not yet incumbent upon the P. C., and it was not possible for it to bring its influence to bear in the desired direction.