— 351 —
As essentially more favourable must be regarded the co-operatively organized domestic industry, which can easily be combined with some horticulture and the like; and if a form of horticulture or other intensive agriculture can be found which, through quick and sufficient returns, or through appropriate organization (say, by the attachment of agricultural and other industries, by the combination of land cultures yielding early returns with those of later profitability, etc.), could be shaped into a commercially sound undertaking, then therein would lie the greatest possibility of a comparatively rapid, cheap colonization, rich in development and suited to Jews.
For even if it is true that a good part of our unnatural situation is to be traced back to the fact that we are not settled on the land and that the peasant callings are lacking to us, yet nothing would be more mistaken than to wish now to transform our pedlars, craftsmen, and industrial workers abruptly into peasants who are to walk behind the plough over great expanses of land. It may grieve us that naturalness, even more than with other town-dwellers, has been lost to us; but all efforts which do not aim at a very gradual return of a corresponding part of the Jewish masses to agriculture are condemned from the outset to failure or to a most unhealthy development.
Of a corresponding part! Here too a grave error is usually committed. Many think simply that "the plough must be put back into the hand of the Jew grown unaccustomed to agriculture." But one need only consider that in a healthy Jewish settlement of a country all callings must be exercised by Jews, and it would surely be madness first to turn the traders and industrial workers one and all into tillers of the soil, only then to lead a great part of the people back again to trade and industry!
The "Garden City" is an excellent way of securing to great masses of the industrial population of larger towns the following advantages.
