Altneuland · Vol. II, No. 9 · September 1905
259printed page
scan 7 of 36
Facsimile · scan 7 of 36
Scan of p. 259
English · AI translation, checked against the German

— 259 —

temperatures was more or less disposed of. And great quantities were continually produced. Now the burden of the imposts soon made itself felt in a most disagreeable manner, and then it was perceived that one had been moving on false paths.

The production of wine was decidedly costly, the imposts were crushing, possibilities of sale were not successively created, and doubts grew loud, cries of anxiety rang out. It was pretended that the misfortune had been rightly grasped.

But it was an empty assertion. For nothing has been undertaken up to now to check the so-called "viticultural crisis" in Palestine, which at most, in its present form, is to be called a wine crisis. That the cause of the crisis was not comprehended is seen from the fact of the reconstitution of the vineyards in Zichron-Jacob after the devastating appearance of the phylloxera in that colony. Here only a part of the old vineyards destroyed by the phylloxera was replanted; but, although it had already been learned that it is difficult to produce table wines cheaply in Palestine and to dispose of them well, sorts were planted here which yield still greater quantities of light wines. In Rishon Lezion there is talk of handing over the cellars to the colonists, and — since we had, forsooth, an over-production — the representatives of the JCA and the colonists are pondering with grave faces the question of destroying the finer sorts, which yield little wine, in order ... to replace them by an equally large area of sorts with a rich yield!!

Whatever may be the nature of the means that will be chosen to meet the so-called crisis of the vineyards already existing, the fact seems definitively settled that, since the wine culture is of necessity an evil, new vineyards must not be planted. The JCA looks decidedly askance at the new plantations, and exerts itself to prevent them; and the colonists would gladly lock up the man who should recommend to them a plantation so thankless for capital and labour.

And yet we maintain that here lies a gross and fateful error. Through the false interpretation of the facts, which has lodged itself in every brain, sin is committed against our land and against