— 222 —
We cannot, however, enter here into the groundings of the views of the two chief tendencies at the Congress, as the author sets them forth. The book interests us in so far as it touches the problem of colonization, and it must be said from the outset that the author treats the questions relating thereto repeatedly and thoroughly. He is without doubt one of the few Zionists who have studied the colonization question more closely among other peoples and in various countries.
In the first chapter Tschlenoff occupies himself with the question of El-Arish. So far as material relating thereto could be gathered together from the scanty literary sources, the author has done it, and it is not his fault if nevertheless his statements are not exactly accurate. In the 3rd chapter his portrayals of the advantages of Palestine as a Jewish region of colonization are thoroughly apposite. Especially interesting, however, are the communications which the author makes in the 4th chapter on the history of the colonization of Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, etc. He examines more closely the causes of the failures or of the slow progress of the European colonial undertakings, and arrives at the conclusion that the momentary distress of the Jewish people cannot be remedied by the settlement of a new, uncultivated country, even if the suitability of the country in question for this purpose stood beyond doubt. The author expresses himself, for the rest, entirely in the sense of the programme of a systematic work of development in Palestine which we have variously recommended in this journal.
The book may be recommended to every Zionist for close study, and we regret that it was not written in a language accessible to the West European Zionists. Its translation into German would be advisable. Soskin.
MISCELLANY.
The Re-opening of Mesopotamia.
From the "Hamburgischer Korrespondent" of 24. 6. 05 we take the following observations on this exceedingly important matter:
"From Constantinople comes the brief report — but one highly significant also in view of the English opposition to the Bagdad Railway project — that Sir William Willcocks, with the support of the English Embassy, has submitted to the Sultan a comprehensive plan for the irrigation of the vilayets of Bagdad and Bassra. The report says nothing more and nothing less than that the English are on the point of beginning the great work of the new laying-out of irrigation canals on the Euphrates and Tigris, and therewith of taking up the work of colonization in those lands! While we have dispatched one 'research commission' after another — the last as recently as the spring of this year — to Mesopotamia, without passing over to practical work, English hydraulic engineers have completed the preliminary works which made it possible for them now to lay before the Sultan a finished project for the re-creation of the canal works in the cultivated regions near Bagdad and Bassra.
Unfortunately it now has the appearance as though in Mesopotamia too the English were to forestall us with their restless, purposeful energy. What does it avail in the end if we give our good money for the building of the Bagdad
