— 71 —
this instruction must not be made uniform, and must be different in Jaffa or Haifa from what it is in Jerusalem, Safed, or Hebron.
The instruction in natural science in the town diverges considerably from that in the village school. In the village, botany must be cultivated much more intensively than in the town. Here, on the other hand, more emphasis is to be laid on elementary physical-chemical instruction. But of the very greatest importance, especially, is the instruction in arithmetic, which in the upper stage must lead directly to a commercial and industrial reckoning. On applied problems a particularly great emphasis is to be laid. In order not to let arithmetic become a mechanical activity of memory, it should in good time be brought into relation with the instruction in geometry; and we may demand of a town school for Jewish children, as a minimum measure, the knowledge of plane geometry, including the similarity of triangles. Here a too-little can sooner do harm than a too-much, while with other theoretical subjects the highest principle to be held fast to, again and again, is that we must aim at achieving a good popular education, but no bad scholar's education.
If already with the village school we attached more value to drawing, for the necessary development of the aesthetic sense, than has hitherto been done, we must emphasize its necessity still much more for the urban elementary school. For a draughtsman finds, also practically, in commerce and above all in all the crafts, his existence and his advancement far more surely than one to whom this ability — which is of eminently practical significance — is denied. Whoever does not wish to degrade the Jewish town-dweller from the outset to sinking, with the progressive development of economic life, through his remaining behind on a lower level, into a factory worker, knows how to measure the value that drawing has. The merchant who does not merely keep books has an enormous advantage over his competitor if he is able to draw. We think here in the first instance of the clothing trade, not of the commission and middleman's trade now customary. The artisan, however, can develop into an art-craftsman — that is, save himself from absolutely certain proletarianization — only if he is able, by his own freehand drawing, if not himself to design models and patterns, then at least