— 19 —
PALESTINE AND NEIGHBOURING REGIONS.
The Fertility of Palestine.
Concerning the fertility of Palestine there unfortunately still prevails the most astonishing ignorance. The reason is doubtless twofold: on the one hand, as it happens, the immediate surroundings of the Jaffa–Jerusalem railway are little cultivated,*) as also the nearer surroundings of Jerusalem, and the road from Jerusalem to the Jordan leads through a very desolate district, in part even through the wilderness of Judaea; on the other hand a Central European finds it difficult to form a correct judgment of the agricultural fitness of the summer-dry Mediterranean region, and often erroneously transfers our standard of judgment to those districts.
Recently two such pronouncements upon the fertility of Palestine have been given currency, which we wish to reproduce here not on account of their expert knowledge, but on account of the importance of their authors. They prove, to be sure, only how superficially the persons in question must have looked at Palestine — presupposing that the reporters reproduced the utterances correctly, that is, without perhaps unconscious accentuation.
The first notice comes from the Israelitisches Familienblatt of 26 May 1904. According to it the well-known author Ludwig Fulda is said to have told an interviewer: "Apart from the Jordan valley, the whole of Palestine is a melancholy waste. Here, in my opinion, no new prosperity can arise. Palestine is dead. On its stony soil no agriculture can be carried on — on what are the people here to live? I cannot therefore believe in a fulfilment of the Zionist idea, which would found here again the homeland for the Jews."
We are in the agreeable position of setting against this notice of the interviewer the following declaration of Dr. L. Fulda. The painter Mr. Hermann Struck in Berlin writes us under date of 2. 1. 05 as follows:
"The utterances of Dr. Ludwig Fulda cited in the article in question are taken from an interview which — as with such 'question-games' it cannot be otherwise — does not correctly reproduce Dr. Fulda's thoughts.
Dr. Fulda authorizes me to declare that he travelled through Palestine only as a passing tourist, and therefore does not himself consider himself qualified to deliver a competent judgment upon the economic possibilities of the country's future. He has only expressed a doubt whether the political and natural conditions of the country give the guarantee for the thriving of a colony numbering millions, but for the rest regards the endeavours of Zionism — whose deep justification he thoroughly acknowledges — in so far as they are fitted to raise the lot of his oppressed fellow-tribesmen, with full sympathy."
The other, perhaps still weightier pronouncement is said to come from the German Imperial Chancellor, Count von Bülow, who according to the "Neue Freie Presse" is said to have told the Viennese author Sigmund Münz (see Berliner Tageblatt, 8 October 1904): "I have not easily seen so unfruitful a country as Palestine." According to the reporter, the Imperial Chancellor therefore
*) In recent years a decided turn for the better is making itself noticeable herein: the surroundings of the railway line afford an ever more friendly sight through the beautiful fields in the plain of Sharon and the cultivated terraces near Jerusalem. The Editors.
