Altneuland · Vol. I, No. 7 · July 1904
206printed page
scan 20 of 38

— 206 —

ever more mechanized with the growth of the undertaking; and conversely, with the growth of the labour force, the mechanical operation of agriculture becomes ever more an art-handicraft.

These considerations make it clear why the agricultural co-operative society, in contrast to its sister in industry, has in all cases that have become known — and even in organizations only remotely akin — succeeded well-nigh without exception.

To make the contrast complete: as a harmonious co-operative society it is not subject to the law of transformation.

Here we can appeal to only very few facts; for the only quite pure labourers' productive co-operative society that has existed hitherto, Rahaline, found its end, after barely two years' existence, through an external misfortune. In this short time it showed not a trace of a tendency to close itself and to degenerate capitalistically; it doubled the number of its members. But it must be conceded that the duration of its existence was too short, and that this one example, even in the case of a longer duration, would not suffice to furnish the inductive proof that this productive co-operative society is not subject to the law of transformation. So we must trust to the psychological analysis, which has after all accomplished something for us, as the complete agreement between the results of our examination so far and empirical reality proves.

That every individual member, as a peasant, has all the characteristic properties of a buyer; that between him and his fellow-members, who are also buyers, there exists the full harmony of all interests which, for example, keeps the urban consumers' union free from transformation — this we have already seen. But we have also seen that the accession of new members, through the cheapening of credit, the intensification of the undertaking, and the winning of a well-paying market, increases instead of diminishing the advantages for every individual. With the accession of new members the divisor of the gain grows, it is true, but for all these reasons the dividend grows much more strongly; and this we recognized above as the cause of the fact that the urban buyers' co-operative society remains open, while the ur-