Altneuland · Vol. I, No. 7 · July 1904
203printed page
scan 17 of 38

— 203 —

measure in which the co-operative society is strengthened by the accession of new members.

Already the winning of the necessary credit at the foundation makes the greatest difficulties. For a credit is to be granted, as pure personal credit, to untried partners of an unproved industrial undertaking, which in the hostile combat of industry must reckon on particularly violent and particularly malignant attacks, because it has a "socialistic" character. That such a credit is obtainable, if at all, only on the most difficult conditions, is evident; and hence the very foundation of industrial trade co-operative societies becomes ever more impossible with economic development, because an ever greater capital is required in order to enter the market on a competitive footing, and because such a capital naturally can neither be raised by labourers through savings nor procured by way of credit. — The same difficulties repeat themselves upon the accession of new members: for the provision of the working-places, the tools, the increased raw materials, and the machinery which becomes applicable with greater division of labour within the workshop, capitals growing ever larger in proportion are necessary, whose procurement becomes ever more hopeless.

But if it has really succeeded, through the help of philanthropists or through the self-sacrifice of the working class, etc., in winning the necessary capitals for the foundation of an industrial productive co-operative society, then threatens the Scylla of the difficulties of sale. The competition of the private capitalists hurls itself upon the young co-operative society with far greater fury still than upon a new competing private firm, and seeks to destroy it with all the means of the combat. Only co-operative societies of highly qualified art-craftsmen, supplying a local market, have in general hitherto been able to withstand this competition; only for such, which can begin on a small scale, is the necessary credit after all obtainable at a pinch. But when such a co-operative society flourishes and strengthens itself by the accession of new members, then the small local market no longer suffices it; it must seek wider sale, and therewith grows ever more deeply into the furious struggle of the great market competition, to which it then in almost all cases succumbs.