— 186 —
SOCIETY REPORTS.
Report of the "Esra", Society for the Support of Agricultural Jews in Palestine and Syria, for 1900, 1901, 1902, and 1903. The society "Esra" numbered at the end of 1903 already over 4000 members scattered over the whole of Germany, and had an income in contributions and donations of 14,497 M. Even though the amount in itself must be described as fairly small, yet the following summary of the moneys employed by the society in Palestine shows that the last years of the society's activity display a marked strengthening of the interest in its work. The society "Esra" was able to employ for the Palestinian colonization-purposes:
from 1884–1891 (8 years) . . . . . . 9,077 M. " 1892–1899 (8 " ) . . . . . . 42,230 " " 1900–1903 (4 " ) . . . . . . 51,000 "
The society "Esra" thus had at its disposal for its purposes in the last four years as much as in the first 16 years of its existence.
Within the years of report 1900–1903, however, the income of the society has unfortunately in the last years undergone a decline. There were, namely, received in contributions and donations in 1900, 15,166 M., in 1901, in a rising tendency, 15,664 M., in 1902, on the other hand, only 13,096 M., and in 1903, 14,497 M. This decline the report explains by the "crisis" in the Jewish colonization of Palestine, which arose in consequence of the passing-over of the colonies belonging to Baron Rothschild to the JCA, in that hereby "the public became acquainted more than hitherto with the defects of Jewish colonization in general and of the colonization of Palestine in particular. They are rooted in the slight agricultural training of the Jewish settlers, as especially in the keenly felt lack of a Jewish official personnel trained both agriculturally and at the same time commercially." The crisis has acted also upon the other colonization-societies. "In France and America the organizations in course of formation have been nipped in the bud. The Chowaweh-Zion societies in England were no longer in a position to meet the obligations they had entered into toward the colony Bnei-Jehudah, and the at first so promising Galician society Ahawath-Zion, with its seat at Tarnow, has wholly succumbed to the machinations of its opponents and has ceased to exist. Even the older sister-society at Odessa has had to pay tribute to the hard times and has suffered a considerable loss in its regular income." We should, to be sure, rather assume that the Galician society Ahawath-Zion became a victim of the over-hasty, unreasonable activity of its directors. If a society has at its disposal but slight pecuniary means, then people without means, who moreover have as yet no notion of the conditions of the land, of agriculture, etc., can in any case furnish no suitable element for settlement. The Galician Jews who were brought by the society Ahawath-Zion to Machanajim in Palestine and then, after many privations, had to leave the land, ought first to have been labourers for a couple of years in the colonies; only then would they have been in a position to take over an economic risk, and that first as tenants and later as proprietors. The colonization-societies would do well if they finally renounced undertaking settlement-experiments with immigrants without means, and limited themselves rather to opening up the land of Palestine in such a way that a self-colonization, that is, a free settlement of settlers, is rendered possible.
