ALTNEULAND
A MONTHLY REVIEW for the economic development of Palestine Organ of the Zionist Commission for the Exploration of Palestine
PUBLISHED BY F. OPPENHEIMER · S. SOSKIN · O. WARBURG.
No. 5. Berlin, May 1904. Year I.
"LARGE-SCALE" AND "SMALL-SCALE" COLONIZATION.
By Dr. S. Soskin.
From the moment when political Zionism, through the efforts to obtain a Charter, began to translate its demands into practice, the expressions "large-scale" and "small-scale" colonization became current in Zionist circles, the so-called large-scale colonization being made dependent upon the obtaining of the Charter and held up as alone desirable, while small-scale colonization — by which designation the colonial experiments hitherto undertaken in Palestine are generally understood — was rejected as mere huckstering.
In what follows we shall attempt to prove that the concepts of "large-scale" and "small-scale" colonization in general use among the Zionists contain in themselves no distinguishing marks of principle; that this distinction rests rather upon a misunderstanding; and that in place of these concepts others are to be set which define more exactly the nature of the path of colonization already entered upon, as well as of that to be struck out for the future. The methods of colonization to be deduced from these amended concepts shall then be designated more precisely.
It is an acknowledged fact that the results of colonization in Palestine hitherto, although they do after all represent a not insignificant acquisition, materially as well as ideally, offer far from what was to be expected in view of the material and intellectual sacrifices expended upon them. The cause of this, however, does not lie in the smallness, the slightness, of the experiments. Experiments are, after all,
