Altneuland · Vol. I, No. 3 · March 1904
79printed page
scan 19 of 36

— 79 —

position of contenting himself with a lower individual rate of gain than before on a diminished quantity of goods, so that his total profit shrinks most painfully from two sides. To this eventuality he cannot expose himself; and so, in every branch of production which is not syndicated, or in which a single producer does not dominate the market almost monopolistically, the consequence of a lowering of the price will be precisely this, that every individual producer increases his output and his supply, and throws the price of his commodity down still lower.

While, then, we saw that the private economic interest of the individual buyer leads him to a manner of acting which harmonizes most happily with the collective interest of all the buyers of the same commodity, we see that, precisely conversely, the private interest of the individual seller leads him to a manner of acting which collides in the strongest conceivable way with the collective interest of the totality of the sellers of the same commodity. We have, then, the fullest harmony among all the buyers, and the fullest disharmony among all the sellers.

Here lies the key to the psychology, and therewith to the manner of acting, of purely economic associations, that is, of the co-operative societies. All co-operative societies of buyers — that is, all associations of such economic subjects as take goods from the market in order to distribute them within the inner circle of ultimate consumers — have at all times exhibited the happiest prosperity. These are the bodies really organized as ultimate consumers: the consumers' union, the credit society, the raw-material, implement, and building societies. I therefore call these bodies the harmonious co-operative societies. On the other hand, the economic bodies of sellers have never attained success and bloom — that is, co-operative societies of such economic subjects as produce goods in the inner circle in order to bring them to market by sale. To these belong above all, and under all circumstances, industrial productive and warehouse societies, and further those forms of the consumers' union and of the credit society which are not organized as ultimate consumers, but which from an inner