Altneuland · Vol. I, No. 1 · January 1904
3printed page
scan 5 of 36
Facsimile · scan 5 of 36
Scan of p. 3
English · AI translation, checked against the German

— 3 —

PALESTINE AS A REGION FOR COLONIZATION.

By Prof. Dr. O. Warburg.

To the endeavours to direct Jewish colonization toward the Orient, and specifically toward Palestine, there is opposed — beside the political and economic difficulties that do indeed exist — above all the objection that the country is unsuited for colonization: that through a thousand years of neglect and misgovernment it has fallen into a hopeless and scarcely remediable condition; that the progressive devastation of the forests has altered the climate; that the thin layer of topsoil which had formed upon the already arid mountain slopes has been washed away by the torrential winter rains, no longer held back by the woodlands, while the valleys and plains, for want of any regulation of the rivers, have turned to swamp and become breeding-grounds of the worst fever-miasmas. To all these factors is ascribed the appalling depopulation of those regions; and no hope of improvement is held to exist — save in the improbable event that reclamation works carried on through many decades, devouring however quite enormous sums, should make good the sins of former ages and create the foundations for a later colonization. Accordingly it would be wholly hopeless for private persons, companies and associations — who hold no permanent governmental power, nor command those quite enormous means which they might expend à fond perdu — to set on foot a sound colonization there; and every pfennig spent upon it is to be regretted, since in Argentina, in Canada, indeed even in Russia, far other successes could be obtained with the same capital outlay.

As for Palestine itself, the land is said to be in any case far too small and too mountainous to receive any number of settlers worth mentioning; and, as regards its climate, to be situated especially unfavourably even among the countries of the Orient.

In view of these weighty objections, it is surely of importance to subject to serious criticism the foundations upon which every colonization in Palestine and the neighbouring countries must build — every colonization coming from without, as well as every internal one. For of what use are the finest and most solid buildings if the ground on which they