— 13 —
…the priesthood, as our great master cited in his debate with him on this matter; but as regards a bastard no one opens his mouth. And what is this that the Gaon, may his light shine, wrote, a proof from the fact that Tosafot did not answer with this practical consequence? For how could they answer by likening permission for the congregation to permission for the priesthood, when there is no proof from Rabbi Yose at all? Rather, the law given to Moses at Sinai is for this present time, as I have written*.
- As for what he wrote concerning the Sifre which I brought, as it is cited in the words of Nahmanides, that from a distant land you shall go and ask which is the way to the house of Yahweh, and as the Sifre says, that he did not wait for a prophet; and on this the Gaon, may his light shine, wrote that from there comes a proof to the contrary, since the Sifre concludes that David did not sacrifice until Gad the prophet came, see there: I have already written that there is no proof from Gad the prophet for our time. For David did not need a prophet for the sacrifice itself, since at that time the high places were permitted everywhere, as is stated in Zevahim 112; and there had already been Shiloh and Nob and Gibeon and all the high places; so how should he need a prophet? Rather, it must be that this is the meaning: after Nathan the prophet said to David, "Thou shalt not build, only thy son", then, granted that it was permitted to offer sacrifices, nevertheless the very place where the everlasting House was to stand was under prohibition by the word of Nathan the prophet, for an altar too is called a Sanctuary; and David was forbidden to build it. And for this Gad the seer came and informed him that although he was not to build the House, it was nevertheless permitted to build an altar and to sacrifice; just as we hold for our own case that one may sacrifice although there is no House, only a built altar. And if so, Nahmanides rightly brought a proof from the Sifre. And I have also already proved in my book that the Sifre and Nahmanides speak only of sacrifice; for if it concerned dwelling in the Land of Israel, that is already proved from "and thou shalt dwell in it", as the Sifre and Nahmanides write explicitly. Rather, it must be that it is with regard to
A Letter from Elijah
On Maharlak's proof, and the rejection, from the law given to Moses at Sinai at the end of Eduyot, Maharit wrote that Tosafot's answer on "the halakhah follows Rabbi Yose", that the practical consequence is for a family [illegible] known, applies also to Maharlak's difficulty; and there is a further proof to the contrary, from Tosafot's not answering as Maharlak answers. Now, what he wrote of a proof to the contrary, and a rejection, I have not understood: is not a practical consequence for everyday deeds preferable to speaking of a practical consequence that does not occur at all? Moreover, what he wrote, that Tosafot's answer applies to Maharlak's difficulty, is likewise not so; for it is explained in the book Ha-Makneh that the dispute of Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Yose concerns only entering the congregation, and he proved this from a verse, but not the matter of priests; and the Beit Shmuel, section 2, proved it from the wording of the Baraita, which mentions only "natan" [illegible] and not the profaned; and he ruled accordingly that even one who knows should not make it public, since he will in the end become fit; but in the case of a profaned one he is obliged to make it known. And if so, Tosafot's answer does not apply in Eduyot. And one cannot say: if so, what does Maharlak mean by "they will become fit", when according to the words of the Beit Shmuel they will not become fit? That is not so, for the intention of the Beit Shmuel is to rule thus because Abaye brought it from him in Kiddushin 71, and so wrote the Ritva there. And if so, in a generation before which the passages, this one of Samuel and this one of Eduyot, are not set side by side, for it does not say "as Samuel, for we learned so in Behirta", as it does for Abaye; and according to this there is a proof from Tosafot for Maharlak. For it is difficult: why did Tosafot not raise a difficulty [illegible] from the law given to Moses at Sinai of Eduyot mentioned above, as Tosafot raised in their difficulty for every place [illegible] like this, where their answer would not have helped? Rather, it must be that there it was obvious to Tosafot that the practical consequence concerns the Service, as Maharlak wrote; whereas with Samuel, who refers only to entering the congregation, on that they rightly raised the difficulty and answered it.
However, on the main foundation there is a great difficulty from the words of Maimonides, end of the Laws of Kings, halakhah 3, that the Messiah will clarify by the holy spirit who is of attested lineage and will set aside those who are not of attested lineage, from what is written, "And he shall sit refining, and purify the sons of Levi"; and this is from the words of Rabbi Hama, Kiddushin 71; but concerning bastards he will not say so, for a family that has been assimilated has been assimilated; and this is according to Rabbi Joshua ben Levi; and he holds that Rabbi Joshua ben Levi and Rabbi Hama do not dispute
