Mount Tzvi 48
…its perfecting, speedily in our days, amen. And in support of the opening of our words, I found that Rabbenu Bahya wrote thus on the portion Vayakhel, cited in the preface to the book Torat ha-Olah: that it is a commandment to inquire into the building of the Tabernacle and its vessels even in its destruction. And all the more at a time like this, when we have merited to see the signs of redemption drawing near and coming, and the voice of the turtledove is heard in our land, it is surely fitting for those who handle the Torah to set their hearts to this halakhah, which the great ones of the generations already opened at a time when there was as yet no prospect whatever of thinking of this matter in practice, and they were very far removed from it; how much more so now, when the Omnipresent in His abundant mercy has brought us near, and this matter is near to us, that it should come up on the table of kings — and who are kings? The Rabbis — it is surely incumbent upon us to examine this as far as our hand reaches. And therefore I said, I too will answer my part, what I have arrived at in this, cursorily, on this question whether it is possible to offer sacrifices at the present time.
Now, as is understood, the essence of this matter depends on clarifying the halakhah of the holiness of the Sanctuary, whether it obtains at the present time or not. And the view of Maimonides is already known (in chapter 6 of the Laws of the Chosen House), that the first sanctification of the place of our Sanctuary sanctified it for the time to come; and he says there: Therefore all the sacrifices are offered, even though there is no House built there, etc. And Rabad objected to him, and these are his words: "This is his own reasoning; and in several places in the Mishnah, if there is no Sanctuary, let them rot; and in the Talmud they said that the partitions had fallen. Evidently, for the one who says that the first sanctification did not sanctify for the time to come, he made no distinction between the Sanctuary and Jerusalem and the rest of the Land of Israel; and not only this, but I say that even according to Rabbi Yose, who said that the second sanctification sanctified for the time to come, he said so only of the rest of the Land of Israel, but of Jerusalem and the Sanctuary he did not say it etc."; end of his words. And according to this, there stands against us a great mountain, the view of Rabad, that we lack today the holiness of the Sanctuary for offering in it burnt-offering and sacrifice. And so our master Rabbi Akiva Eger wrote to the Gaon Rabbi Tzvi Kalischer, that we have come to the dispute of Maimonides and Rabad mentioned above; and to this the Gaon our teacher Rabbi N. replied to him, and these are his words: At first sight this has no bearing on our case, for according to the one who says it was not sanctified, it is permitted to offer even outside, as is stated (Megillah 10a): I have heard that they offer in the House of Onias etc.; end of his words. And our master Rabbi Akiva Eger kept silent before these words of his. And in my humble opinion the words are astonishing, in view of what we have learned (Megillah 9b): This is the rule: whatever is vowed or freely offered is offered on a high place, and whatever is not vowed or freely offered is not offered on a high place; and so it is stated in Zevahim (117a), and also in the Mishnah (there, 112); and it is explained that communal sacrifices are not offered on an individual's high place. And if so, how is it possible to offer by force of the argument "whichever way you take it": that according to Maimonides he duly offers, because it has the holiness of the Sanctuary, and if you should say it is as Rabad holds, he will offer under the law of a high place? But they differ in the laws of offering, and it is certainly not offered at all; for under the law of a high place it is in turn impossible to offer a communal sacrifice, and an individual's sacrifice likewise cannot be offered, for perhaps it is as Maimonides holds, that it has the holiness of the Sanctuary, and it is impossible to offer an individual's sacrifice because of impurity, which was permitted only for the community. And one cannot force into the intention of our teacher Rabbi Tzvi of blessed memory that, in wishing to permit the offering by reason of the permission of a high place according to Rabad's view, he holds that this counts as a great high place and communal sacrifices are duly offered on it; for this is not so, since it is explained in the Tosefta at the end of Zevahim: Which is a great high place? At the time when the high places are permitted, the Tent of Meeting pitched in its usual way etc. Hence an altar alone does not suffice to count as a communal high place without a Tent of Meeting. And at first sight one could prove this from the passage of the Talmud in Megillah there, where we say: It follows that Rabbi Eliezer holds that it was not sanctified for the time to come; and therefore, when they were building in the Sanctuary, they made curtains for the Sanctuary
