Essay on Holy Things
…and Ran, and nothing further. 4) On knowing the place of the altar by means of the Western Wall, the Rabbi, may his light shine, raised a difficulty from Zevahim 62, where we say: "Granted the House, its form was recognisable (Rashi explains: the foundations of the walls); but the altar, how did they know it?" And it answers that they had a prophet. Evidently they knew the foundations of the Court, and even so they needed a prophet. And I replied to him that this difficulty does not concern me, for against the Talmud itself it is difficult: why did they need a prophet, when they could have measured? But in truth there is no difficulty, for Rashi explained there, at the words "One testified to them": concerning the altar, that it has room to be enlarged up to sixty. End of quotation. And if so, what did knowing the measurement help them? For they needed to add to the first altar, and they did not know at what place the sanctity of the addition up to sixty would begin, and for this they needed a prophet; and so it is in Maimonides' Commentary on the Mishnah, Middot chapter 2. And further: since they did not find the foundation of the altar, and the Court was large, they could not know which place in the Court had been made fit for the altar. Which is not so for us, to whom all the measurements to the north and to the south were taught in Tractate Middot. And I found further support in the Midrash Rabbah on the Song of Songs, on the verse "My beloved is like a gazelle; behold, he stands behind our wall": behind the Western Wall of the Temple, which the Holy One, blessed be He, swore concerning it that it will never be destroyed; and the Priest's Gate and the Hulda Gate were never destroyed. End of quotation. If so, there will be a great sign from the Wall and from the gates. And the Rabbi, may his light shine, devised a further means, by way of the Foundation Stone, and there is no need to enlarge. The Gaon, may his light shine, also brought support from the Midrash Rabbah, section 64, that in the days of Rabbi Joshua ben Hananiah permission came from the king to build the Temple, and they accepted it and wished to build it; and afterwards the enemies informed against them and the king stopped them. And behold, even then there were no prophets, and without doubt it was possible to find the place of the altar, as above.
-
Further, the Rabbi, may his light shine, brought a correct observation: since we hold, in Maimonides, chapter 5 of the Laws of the Vessels of the Sanctuary, that a priest is forbidden to serve until they inaugurate him with the griddle-cakes, how will they inaugurate him, when the griddle-cakes are not a community sacrifice and do not override impurity? And I replied to this that the Mishneh le-Melekh wrote there (halakhah 16) that if the High Priest went ahead before he had brought the tenth of an ephah, his service is valid; and he brought proof: for if it were invalid, then where a disqualification befell the High Priest on the Day of Atonement, where we hold that another enters in his stead, perforce he enters without the tenth of an ephah, since an individual's sacrifice does not override the Day of Atonement; see there. Here you have it: wherever the need of the community depends on it, it is permitted at the outset without the griddle-cakes; and all the more so in our case, where no service at all would be possible, it counts as after the fact, and his service is valid without inauguration.
-
Further, the Rabbi, may his light shine, raised a difficulty from what we say in Zevahim (48): "But now, should the whole of the slaughtering of holy things not be taught? It is a halakhah for the Messiah! Rather: expound and receive reward." And so it is in Sanhedrin (51). And if it were so, the halakhah would need to be taught, for perhaps permission will be given to build an altar; perforce the anonymous Talmud holds that it was not sanctified for the time to come, and that it is forbidden to offer nowadays, like Rabbi Hayyim and not like the Tosafot Yom Tov and the Jerusalem Talmud in Ma'aser Sheni. Thus far from his precious words. And I replied to him: behold, in Tosafot there in Zevahim they wondered at this saying, since we find halakhot and it does not object "for the Messiah"; and they answered that only Rav Yosef holds so; and they answered further that it does not object "a halakhah for the Messiah" except where one also commits a transgression. And I explained the two answers of Tosafot. As for what they wrote, that it is Rav Yosef who holds so, it seems to me that Rav Yosef follows his own view, for this matter depends on a dispute of the Amoraim. For in Sanhedrin (99) Samuel said: "There is no difference between this world and the days of the Messiah except the subjection to the kingdoms alone." That is, he differs there with Rabbi Yohanan, who said: "All the prophets prophesied only for the days of the Messiah, but as for the world to come, 'no eye has seen', etc." And Rabbi Yohanan holds that all