Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
73scan
of 139

Essay on Holy Things 37

…like Rashi or like Rabbi Hayyim; and as his honour the Gaon, may his light shine, also wrote, that in Shevuot it is proven that it does not hold like Rabbi Hayyim, since they raised a difficulty against Rabbi Nahman from these Mishnahs; if so, this is not like Rabbi Hayyim. And as for what he wrote, that if Rabad does not hold like Rabbi Hayyim, what will he say to these Mishnahs from which a difficulty is raised against Rabbi Yitzhak: there is no difficulty, for in this the Tannaim hold that it is no difficulty, as is brought in Tosafot, Zevahim (61); and that one of "they shall rot" is also proven from the anonymous Talmud. 2) Further, the Gaon our teacher Rabbi Eliyahu, may his light shine (of blessed memory), wrote, and these are his words: What his honour wrote, that the impediment of impurity does not apply to the community, he wrote well, and all the community sacrifices were permitted without hindrance; and he rightly rejected also the words of the Gaon of Pressburg, of blessed memory. And there is a point to be raised in this matter (for it is always better if we raise it ourselves, and do not wait until another pronounces on it and says that we did not know of this): perhaps, since there is no way to offer on the Day of Atonement — for there is no High Priest, and there are no garments of the High Priest, and there is no shamir for the stones, and also there is no knowledge of the stones — and since it is impossible to offer on the Day of Atonement, even if they are allowed to offer all the year, how can they be called daily offerings if it is not daily, etc. And all this is only a remark, so that people should not come to cast doubt. Thus far from his words. And I replied that his words are right in this, that one must satisfy the doubters, even though he himself does not decide it to be true; but in my humble opinion there is not even the beginning of a doubt in this. For when they had no lambs for some time in the days of Aristobulus (as is mentioned in the Talmud), did they afterwards stop offering in that year when lambs arrived? And likewise in the days of the Greeks, when the Hasmoneans defeated them at Hanukkah, did they then not offer because they had ceased on the Day of Atonement and at one time or another? Rather, certainly this is no doubt at all. 3) On the matter of the presumptive status of the priests: a long discussion, that according to Maimonides we are concerned even without a flaw with regard to heave-offering, for only Rashi and Rabbenu Tam hold that only where there is a flaw, as in the case of Ezra, are we concerned; and nevertheless, for the practical law, the Gaon, may his light shine, agreed with me and brought support for my approach, and these are his words: But with all this, the words of his honour, may his light shine, are not to be set aside; for the Beit Yosef (in section 2) on Even ha-Ezer asked why Rif and Rosh did not bring the whole Mishnah and the discussion of Kiddushin (page 76), and also did not bring that of Ketubot (24, 25); and he answered that they hold that the whole discussion follows Rabbi Meir, who requires investigation, but according to the Rabbis, who differ with Rabbi Meir, all the priests and the women are presumed fit and need no investigation at all, and if there are objectors some slight investigation is required, and this is understood of itself and need not be spelled out in the halakhah. So the Rabbi the Beit Yosef answered. And still, if they held like Maimonides that with heave-offering of Torah law we are concerned even in our case, they ought to have brought this law, etc. Rather, certainly Rif holds that in this too no investigation is needed, etc. And if so, we certainly hold like Rif and Rosh (and Rashi and Rabbenu Tam); and the Tur too differs from Maimonides (in section 2), and the Ran too wrote like Rabbenu Tam in Ketubot (24, 26), and Maimonides stands alone in this. And it is possible that even for Maimonides, who was concerned, it is not a reasoning of Torah law, but only Ezra was stringent in the matter because he had many priests, which is not so when one judges concerning all the priests; and much as his honour wrote, that one does not set aside a great commandment for the sake of a suspicion. Thus far the words of our teacher Rabbi Eliyahu, may his light shine (of blessed memory). And I replied to him that I need not enlarge further, since in his discussion he concluded by agreeing with me on the practical law; but in my opinion Maimonides too agrees, for it is known that lineage is more stringent than heave-offering, and if regarding lineage he wrote that a flaw is required, all the more so regarding heave-offering. Rather, it must be said that Maimonides, regarding heave-offering, speaks of a time when there was a flaw, or of when there is a flaw in the present time, or that he was stringent where there is no need of a commandment, as his honour too agreed with me. And further it may be said that Rabbi Meir follows his own view, that he takes account of the minority and requires investigation, and the Rabbis follow their view, that they do not take account of the minority and need no investigation; and we hold like the Rabbis, as the Rabbi the Beit Yosef wrote. And as for Maimonides, it may be said that he holds that wherever an easy investigation is possible, it counts as "it is possible to clarify", and we do not rely on the majority; and consequently, where an easy investigation is not possible, Maimonides agrees with Rif and Rosh and Rashi and Rabbenu Tam