Seeking — First Essay — Zion 13
…yet will I gather others to him, besides his gathered ones"; and he explained that at first He will gather many of the dispersed of Israel, but not all of them; and after the war of Gog He said, "Yet will I gather others to him, besides his gathered ones": that they will be gathered a second time in addition to the gathered ones, who were gathered already. And so it appears to me to be made plain from the mouth of Yahweh in our holy Torah: "Then Yahweh thy God will return thy captivity, and have compassion upon thee, and will return and gather thee from all the peoples, whither Yahweh thy God hath scattered thee." He said "will return" twice: for at first He "will return thy captivity", only the uttermost part of it, "and have compassion upon thee" through this, for your iniquity will be pardoned through the sweet savour of your sacrifices; and then "He will return and gather thee from all the peoples" a second time, a great ingathering, the whole of it, and He will then bring them on swift beasts, and kings shall be their foster-fathers. And it also appears to me clear that it was of the beginning of the redemption that some of our Rabbis of blessed memory said, "There is no difference between this world and the days of the Messiah except subjection to the kingdoms alone"; and it is in Sanhedrin (99). And these days, before Gog comes, are called the days of the Messiah, for these days will work and bring it about that the eternal Messiah will come, as in the saying of the Jerusalem Talmud mentioned above; but when the complete redemption comes, after the war of Gog, then wonderful are the works of Yahweh: new heavens and a new earth, and the covenant with death shall be annulled, and He will swallow up death for ever. And it was not of these days, God forbid, that they said "There is no difference between this world, etc.", but only of the time before Gog; and this is clear. And similar to this wrote Ha-Kotev in the Preface in Ein Ya'akov on the saying of Rabbi Hillel, "There is no Messiah for Israel", that he explained his words: that Yahweh, blessed be He, will put it into the heart of the kings to acknowledge the truth, and then the prophecy of Zephaniah will be fulfilled, "I will turn a pure language"; see there.
- Isaiah the prophet, peace be upon him, taught the people yet more knowledge concerning our way, in saying (Isaiah 27): "Those that come shall Jacob cause to take root; Israel shall blossom and bud, and they shall fill the face of the world with fruit, etc. And it shall come to pass in that day, etc., and ye shall be gathered one by one, O children of Israel. And it shall come to pass in that day, that a great trumpet shall be blown, etc." Behold, he made known that all Israel will not come at one time, but "ye shall be gathered one by one", like one who beats out the grain from the ear and brings in his corn little by little. And he said, "Those that come shall take root": those that come at first, at the beginning of the redemption, Jacob shall cause to take root, like a root sown in the earth to make a great growth spring up; and afterwards Israel shall blossom and bud in the holy soil, for the root will put forth a blossom; they will multiply and grow great, until "they shall fill the face of the world with fruit", for they will go on growing ever greater until their fruit is found in the world and all that fills it, for all the nations too shall flow unto Zion. And of the end of the redemption he said, "A great trumpet shall be blown, and they shall come that were lost in the land of Assyria, etc." And so he said further (Isaiah 11): "And it shall come to pass in that day, that Yahweh shall set His hand again the second time to acquire the remnant of His people, which shall remain, from Assyria, etc." Here you have it before you, that there will be a first ingathering and a second ingathering; and "he shall strike his roots" in the first, for those of the children of Jacob who come of themselves will root their stock in the Land, and afterwards Israel shall blossom and bud at an exalted level.
And in the Talmud we find in Sanhedrin (97) that Rabbi Akiva erred concerning Ben Koziba, who reigned in Betar, that he would bring about the Messiah; and it was what Haggai said, "Yet a little while, and I will shake the heavens and the earth"; that is to say, before the completeness of the redemption comes there will be one kingdom for a little while, and that is Ben Koziba, and afterwards "I will shake the heavens and the earth". And far be it that the Tanna Rabbi Akiva erred in the true explanation of the verse; rather, it is clear that this is indeed the explanation of the verse: that at the beginning of the redemption there will be a little sprouting of salvation, that they will be gathered one by one from the exile to make a settled land, and afterwards they will offer up a sweet savour and it will be accepted for them, and afterwards "I will shake the heavens and the earth." Only in this did Rabbi Akiva err, that he held that Ben Koziba was the "little" kingdom; and it was not so, for the vision is yet
