The Gate of Zion
…agrees with the rest of the Tannaim and Amoraim that it is a commandment of the Torah to go up to the Land of Israel even from Babylon, and all the more so from other lands; and this is clear.
-
Concerning this great commandment even in the present time, I shall copy the words of Maharit in his novellae on Ketubot (folio 110), in the passage beginning "He says to go up": Tosafot wrote: And Rabbi Hayyim used to say that now there is no commandment to dwell in the Land of Israel, for there are several commandments dependent on the Land which one cannot take care to observe. And this is a matter of astonishment, for there are several commandments which one can fulfil if he wishes to take the obligation of them upon himself, etc., and one who fears Heaven will fulfil his duty in all of them, etc. And further, dwelling in the Land of Israel is a commandment of the Torah, and Nahmanides counted it in the reckoning of the commandments: "And you shall possess it and dwell in it", even in the present time; and we say that a child who walks four cubits in the Land of Israel is assured that he is a son of the World to Come, and that the dead outside the Land do not live, and that one buried in the Land of Israel is as though buried beneath the altar, and many things which we say there; and all of it holds for the present time, since the Land still stands in its holiness. It is a prevailing halakhah that wherever there is no danger, one compels going up to the Land of Israel, and no one takes heed of this view of Rabbi Hayyim of blessed memory, and in the Tosafot of the Rosh it is not found. Thus far the words of Maharit of blessed memory. And so Maimonides decided it as the halakhah, and so we hold in the Shulhan Arukh, Even ha-Ezer, even in the present time, and not like Rabbi Hayyim mentioned above.
-
Further, Maharit raised the difficulty there that there is a contradiction in the words of Rabbi Yehudah, for we say (there, 111): Rabbi Yehudah said in the name of Samuel: Just as it is forbidden to go out from the Land of Israel to Babylon, so it is forbidden to go out from Babylon to other lands; which implies that it is permitted to go up from Babylon to the Land of Israel. And Maharit was driven to answer: this is his own view, and that is his master's. And this is forced, for in such a case the Talmud would have explained it expressly, as in other passages. And it seems to me that the contradiction can be resolved. For there Tosafot raised a difficulty, in the passage beginning "To Babylon they shall be carried": Although this verse is written of the first exile, one may say that of the second exile the verse is the more particular. Thus far their words. And this is forced, for the positive commandment of Jeremiah had already been annulled, as I wrote above. And Maharit answered, and these are his words: That in Babylon they had been there from the first time, for we do not find that they were exiled to Babylon at the second destruction, and so it is implied, etc.; hence they were there from the first exile onward, and they ought to have gone up and did not go up, etc.; and since they did not go up in the days of Ezra, they are still under this warning; but if those who had gone up went there, it is not implied that they may not go out. Thus far Maharit. And according to this the contradiction is resolved: Rav Yehudah knew that most of the people of Babylon were of those who had not gone up in the days of Ezra, and if so, presumptively all of them are forbidden, for we follow the majority; but Rabbi Yehudah, saying it in the name of Samuel, spoke only of other lands, since there is a practical difference for those who have a written record of lineage showing that they are of those who went up, or who came from other lands to Babylon, or it is a commandment for them to go up to the Land of Israel; therefore he mentioned only other lands and not the Land of Israel. And according to this Maimonides too is reconciled (at the end of chapter 5 of the Laws of Kings), who first brought the great commandment to go up to the Land of Israel, and afterwards brought the words of Rabbi Yehudah in the name of Samuel mentioned above, "Just as it is forbidden, etc.", and brought the verse "To Babylon they shall be carried"; and they wondered at it, for according to this verse it is forbidden even to the Land of Israel, while Maimonides forbids only to other lands. But according to what was said above it is well: the verse which Maimonides brought is there because there is a practical difference for those who did not go up in the days of Ezra, for whom the warning of Jeremiah remains; but in this Maimonides decided like the other Amoraim, that the majority are not of those who did not go up; therefore to the Land of Israel it is permitted, and it is well. This also reconciles the words of the Kesef Mishneh there, whose words there are astonishing, for he wrote that the Amoraim too hold so, while in truth in the Talmud it is the reverse; but according to what was said above it is well, for in this point which Rabbi Yehudah holds, concerning those who did not go up in the days of Ezra, one may say that all hold so; and consider it carefully. And it follows from this that in the present time