The Gate of Zion
Which is an introduction to the book First to Zion.
- There are those who devise deep counsel to do away with the holy way, saying that at present there is no commandment to go up to Mount Zion, to the holy soil, for the commandment of dwelling in the Land of Israel was stated only for the time of the Sanctuary; and they hold fast to a crooked way on the basis of the words of Rabbi Judah in Ketubot (110): "Whoever goes up from Babylonia to the Land of Israel transgresses a positive commandment, as it is said, 'They shall be carried to Babylon, and there shall they be until the day that I visit them.'" So it comes up in their misled minds. And I shall make clear in this that it is only the argument of the evil inclination. First, Rabbi Judah spoke only of going from Babylonia to the Land of Israel, but from other countries Rabbi Judah certainly agrees with all the Amoraim there that it is a great commandment to go up; and as is said also in the Sifrei (section 80): Dwelling in the Land of Israel is equal to all the commandments in the Torah. End of quotation. And further we shall make clear that in this time Rabbi Judah agrees that even from Babylonia it is a commandment to go up, for there is great difficulty with Rabbi Judah. First, would he really dispute an anonymous Mishnah (Ketubot there): "All may compel to go up to the Land of Israel, and none may compel to leave; if he says to go up and she does not wish it, she is compelled, even from a fine dwelling to a poor one"? And likewise concerning slaves there: they compel on account of the settlement of the Land of Israel (and it makes no distinction at all between Babylonia and other countries). And further there is a difficulty for Rabbi Judah: the verse says only, "and there shall they be until the day that I visit them," and surely they had already been visited through the prophets Ezra, Nehemiah, Haggai, Zechariah and Malachi, who commanded them to go up; Ezra fined the priests who did not go up. And since He visited them and the positive commandment of Jeremiah was annulled, how did it return to its place? Surely Jeremiah made it conditional, "until the day that I visit," and they had already been visited. And further there is a difficulty: surely a prophet is not permitted to introduce anything new against the Torah, except as a ruling for the hour; and how could Jeremiah introduce a positive commandment against the commandment of the Torah, which we derive from "And you shall take possession of the land and dwell in it," as Nahmanides wrote, and so it is in the Sifrei and in the Yalkut? Without Rabbi Judah, it would be well enough: one may say that for the seventy years it was as a ruling for the hour; but for Rabbi Judah, who holds that it stands in this time, it is very difficult, as above.
Therefore it seems clear that Rabbi Judah relied on what is said in the Talmud, that Ezra at first did not go up to the Land of Israel while Baruch son of Neriah was still alive, for he learned Torah from him, and after Baruch's death he went up. Hence the positive commandment of the study of the Torah overrides the positive commandment of dwelling in the Land; and for this reason Jeremiah warned them not to go up, for in Babylonia there were then the craftsmen and the smiths, and Daniel and his companions, a seat of learning for the Torah, whereas in the Land of Israel there was no place of Torah. And so after the destruction, when the academies were in Babylonia, as is known, and as Rabbi Johanan said, "It is theirs" (Sukkah 44b, and Rashi's explanation there), then the positive commandment returned to its place, that they should not go up from Babylonia to the Land of Israel. And know this, for Rav Joseph and Rabbah and Abaye (there, 111) said that even from Pumbedita to Bei Kubei it is forbidden; although Bei Kubei too was in Babylonia, nevertheless in Pumbedita there was an academy for the Torah. And so Rashi explained there explicitly, in the comment beginning "So it is forbidden": to leave Babylonia, because there are academies there which spread Torah continually. End of quotation. You see explicitly that the chief reason is on account of the academies; and if so, now that there are no academies in Babylonia, Rabbi Judah too