Tract: The Ordination of Elders 69
…my previous words. 3) As appears from the Letter of Ordination, one of the chief reasons for which they renewed the ordination was that at that time many of the forced converts of Spain came and wished to repent, but their hearts smote them for the transgressions for which they were liable to excision, and they wished to be exempted by flogging, according to the law that all who are liable to excision who have been flogged are exempted from their excision; and it is derived from the verse "then thy brother shall be dishonoured before thine eyes": once he has been flogged, he is thy brother. That is, only when witnesses warned them of flogging, at the time of the transgression; and if there was no warning before witnesses he is not exempted from excision by flogging, even by a court; and he brings many proofs there. And our teacher Rabbi Ya'akov Berab brought proofs that even if he comes to the court by way of repentance he is likewise exempted from excision by flogging. And in my humble opinion: behold, Tosafot in tractate Yevamot 88a, at the words "A man came", and these are their words: "And if you should say: since there are two who say he died, even if there are a hundred who say he is alive, what of it? Surely two are like a hundred. And one may answer that with regard to a thing that is seen and known to all, Rav would not have said so; but with two witnesses she does not go out"; thus far their words. And so they answer on the discussion in Bava Kamma 74, concerning the slain man who came on his own feet; see there. If so, we can say: as for the forced converts of Spain, is it not a thing known to all the world that they transgressed there prohibitions punishable by excision, as is understood from what is known in the chronicles? For were not all their steps watched, so that they should not keep the Torah even in secret? If so, it is as if there were witnesses here, and it is even better than witnesses. And as for the warning, has not Maimonides already ruled, in chapter 2 of the Laws of Sanhedrin, halakhah 2, that the reason a warning is required, whether for an unlearned man or for a scholar, is that warning was given only to distinguish between the unwitting and the deliberate? And see there in the Kesef Mishneh and the Lehem Mishneh, and you will see that in such a case as that of the Jews of Spain it does not apply at all that they should need warning; and if so they were certainly exempted from excision by flogging. 4) Surely, when there are ordained men among us in the Land of Israel, they will be obliged to intercalate years and to fix months; and if so, how by this shall we decide the dispute between Maimonides and Nahmanides, that according to Maimonides seventy-one are required and according to Nahmanides three suffice? And how will they set aside the fixing of the years and the festivals according to the calculation which is in our hands from the days of Hillel the Second? And in my humble opinion the commandment of sanctifying the month is incumbent on the court only if witnesses come and testify that they saw the moon; but if witnesses did not come, the court is under no obligation to sanctify months. And so we have learnt in tractate Rosh Hashanah 30b: "At first they used to receive testimony about the new moon all day; once the Levites erred in the song; they ordained that they should not receive the witnesses if they came from the meal-offering onwards"; see there in Rashi's commentary and Tosafot, on the explanation of "once the Levites erred in the song". If so, it is difficult: how did they set aside the positive commandment of sanctifying the month because it happened once that the Levites erred in the song, and especially according to the one who says that if it was seen on the thirty-first day they do not sanctify it? Rather, certainly, if the witnesses did not testify that they saw the moon, no positive commandment to sanctify it is incumbent on the court. And now we can act in this way: we shall teach the public that they should not come to testify if they see the moon. And have we not learnt: "There was a large courtyard there etc.", and they used to make great feasts so that they should be accustomed to come? So it was not easily that they found witnesses for the sighting of the moon. And there remains only the concern that perhaps the court themselves will see the moon by day, so that they could sanctify without witnesses, since hearing is not greater than seeing; and this is a remote thing; if so, we shall not put ourselves into this doubt. And further, Nahmanides of blessed memory wrote, and these are his words: "And according to all this we shall say that the act in which Rabbi Hillel the Prince and his court agreed upon this calculation and instituted it for the generations, in months and in years — I read concerning them, 'These are the appointed seasons of Yahweh which you shall proclaim'; this matter is the establishment of the months and the festivals today
