Tract: The Ordination of Elders
…Sanhedrin: "It seems to me that if all the Sages agreed etc."; and Rashba has already written something similar at the beginning of the chapter "An Ox that Gored Four and Five"; thus far his words. But in truth one may raise a difficulty against this, for the Rosh himself wrote at the end of the first chapter of Bava Kamma, and these are his words: "And nowadays, since there are no ordained experts in the Land of Israel, we do not fix a time for him." Afterwards I found that the Pilpula Harifta had already taken this up, in the chapter Ha-Mafkid. And I am further astonished, for Alfasi in the chapter Ha-Mafkid did not bring this matter, "if he summons him to judgment", because we have no ordained men now in the Land of Israel, and at the end of the first chapter of Bava Kamma Alfasi brought this matter explicitly, "if he summons him to judgment in the Land of Israel"; and this requires great study. Unless we say that both the Rif and the Rosh hold the view of Maimonides, and for this reason each of them mentioned in one place "if he summons him to judgment", to hint to us that there can be ordained men according to the view of Maimonides; and they did not trouble to mention it in every place, since in their days there were no ordained men in the Land of Israel. And now I have seen, in the tract of the Gaon, the head of the rabbinical court of Shkud, which appeared in the year 671, that he brings in the name of the great Rabbi and Gaon, Rabbi Aharon Mendel Kohen, a proof that Maimonides did not retract in the Yad from what he wrote in the Commentary on the Mishnah, from what Maimonides wrote in the Laws of Shofar, chapter 2, halakhah 9, where he wrote: "And in this time, when the Temple is destroyed, in every place where there is a fixed court they blow the shofar on the Sabbath"; and this is a proof to which there is no reply; thus far his words. And in my humble opinion this is no proof at all; on the contrary, from there it is evident that Maimonides speaks only of the time after the Destruction, for he wrote at the end of the halakhah, "and they blow on the Sabbath only in the court that sanctified the month", and this applies precisely after the Destruction, when they still sanctified the months; but the restoration of ordination according to the view of Maimonides is precisely for the laws of fines and the like, but not to sanctify months, as is explained in the tract of our teacher Rabbi Ya'akov Berab, that the calculation handed down to us from Hillel the Second shall not be changed until the coming of the righteous redeemer. And so the Kesef Mishneh cited, on the ruling of Maimonides, Rosh Hashanah 29 and 30, where the Mishnah and the Baraita there refer to the time after the Destruction. Now let us go through the words of the Ralbah, on account of which he opposed the ordination, and say some things to resolve them, with the help of Yahweh, blessed be He, who graciously gives man knowledge. The chief reasons of the Ralbah are: 1) What is this ordination? This ordination would give the ordained man the title Rav in place of Rabbi under the first ordination; and in this time it has already become the custom to call every scholar by the name Rav and also Rabbi, and it is no longer possible to take this title from them, even though they are not fit for ordination, so as not to slight their honour and put them to shame. However, in my humble opinion there is indeed a great difference. For we see that indeed it is the custom to call every scholar Rav or Rabbi, but this is only in writing; when they speak face to face, they call "Rabbi" only the scholar of their own town who serves there in the office of the rabbinate, but not in another place. But this we do see, that the great men of Israel are called "Rabbi" to their face in every place they come to. And it is related in the life of our master the Hatam Sofer of blessed memory that when he was received as head of the rabbinical court in the city of Pressburg there was there a famous scholar, a Gaon in Torah, and in the first days after the coming of the Gaon mentioned above he spoke with him in the second person, and afterwards, when he saw the greatness of the wisdom and genius of our master the Hatam Sofer, he at once began to call him "Rabbi" when he spoke with him face to face. If so, this will be the title of honour of the ordained: that they will be called "Rabbi" to their face in every single place, not only in writing; and so it is evident from the language of the Talmud there: "he called him 'Rabbi'" (Sanhedrin 13). 2) That according to the view of Maimonides the agreement of all the Sages of Israel in the Land of Israel is required, and a majority is not enough. In my humble opinion, although there is room for debate on this, we have already said that, with the help of Yahweh, blessed be He, they can bring it about that it shall be with the agreement of all the Sages of Israel, from all our dispersed brethren the children of Israel. And this is the intention of Maimonides in the Commentary on the Mishnah; see