Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
135scan
of 139

68 Tract: The Ordination of Elders

…and immediately upon its founding it will spread rays of light over the face of all the earth, and they shall fill the face of the world with fruit. Be strong, and let us strengthen ourselves; let us gird on the remnant of our strength, let us bring stone to stone and course to course, to build this high and exalted edifice, which is the establishment of a Great Sanhedrin in Jerusalem, the holy city. And behold, as I explained above with Yahweh's help, the counsel is in this manner: that all the communities of Israel scattered in all the world, that is, the majority of the communities, shall elect their rabbis, that they may be their representatives, and they shall come to Jerusalem, the holy city, to a great assembly together with the sages of the Land of Israel; and they all shall select from among themselves the greatest among them, and he shall be the first ordained; and afterwards they shall select from among themselves up to the number of the Sanhedrin, and the first ordained shall ordain them according to law; and afterwards they shall select from among themselves the head of the Sanhedrin; and in this manner it will be according to law even in the view of Maimonides, who in this manner was not in doubt at all. They shall also be the representatives of all Israel in all the lands, and their agents in every matter; and as soon as all their matters are appointed, it shall be according to the law of the Torah, and only what they shall teach and declare shall all Israel do, and they shall not rebel against their word nor budge the slightest bit from their words. And since there are found among us, in all the lands of our dispersion, learned householders of great distinction who do not serve in the crown of the rabbinate, therefore the counsel offered is that all these learned men, when they receive the ordination customary now from a rabbi renowned in his place, shall then also take part in the election and in the appointment of the Sanhedrin in Jerusalem, the holy city, for so justice requires, that their place should not be wanting. However, when all the rabbis gather in the Holy Land for a great assembly concerning this, they will surely arrange the manner of the election so that it shall be fitting and acceptable to all our brethren in every place, that is, that the elected shall be according to the number of the sages of each and every land; for from the land of Russia there will be the majority, for there is the majority in number and the majority in stature of our brethren; and so every land according to the number of its sages. Now let us cast an eye upon the ordination that existed in the days of our master the Beit Yosef of blessed memory. Ordination was abolished in the year 89 of the fifth millennium; if so there are now 1590 years since the abolition of ordination; and in the year 197 of the fifth millennium our teacher Rabbi Ya'akov Berab endeavoured to renew ordination in the Land of Israel according to the view of Maimonides of blessed memory, and the centre of the Land of Israel was then in Safed. And twenty-five great rabbis gathered there, and they appointed our teacher Rabbi Ya'akov Berab as an ordained rabbi and wrote the Letter of Ordination, as it is written at the end of the book Responsa of the Ralbah; and he afterwards ordained ten great rabbis, and among them were our masters the Beit Yosef and the Mabit, may their merit shield us. However, the Ralbah, who was then the master of the place in Jerusalem, the holy city, found some reasons on which to hang his opposition; however, according to the halakhah we need not enlarge much, since our master the Beit Yosef — with whom two hundred rabbis agreed that the halakhah should be according to him in all his words, as is brought in the book Shem ha-Gedolim of the Hida of blessed memory, and he brings there also that almost from Heaven they agreed that the halakhah should be according to him — he and his colleagues, our masters, accepted to be among the ordained; if so, according to this we need not be concerned at all for the view of the Ralbah, which is the view of an individual against many who made it a halakhah in practice. The Beit Yosef also mentions this halakhah in the Tur, Hoshen Mishpat, section 295, at its end, and this is his language: "And as for what (the Rosh) wrote at the beginning of the chapter ha-Mafkid, and the practical difference nowadays, although we do not judge cases of fines: if he seized it we do not take it from him, or we summon him to judgment in the Land of Israel — it is difficult for me: since now there are no ordained men, if we summon him to judgment, what of it? And it is possible that now too it is possible for ordained men to be found, according to what Maimonides of blessed memory wrote in chapter 4 of the Laws of