Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
133scan
of 139

67 Tract: The Ordination of Elders

…the crooked shall be made level; all the entanglements and tortuous windings that are in our nation will melt like wax before light and like snow before the heat of the sun. The darkness will give up its place to the great light. The benefit that will come from this it is superfluous for us to explain, and the book is too short to explain and detail it all, for anyone who has a brain in his skull will understand of himself that this thing has the power to set us upon the summit of success and of spiritual happiness. The end of the matter is that, just as it is agreed among physicians that there is a certain known remedy which is a general remedy for all evil diseases, so this thing is a general remedy for all the evil diseases that have become entwined upon us during the whole course of this long time of the Exile. My masters and friends! I am not the first in this proposal. Men greater and better than I preceded me some years before, and especially the Gaon Rabbi Yehiel Mikhel Hausha, may Yahweh preserve him and grant him life, head of the rabbinical court of the city of Shkud in the province of Kovno, who published a special tract concerning this in the year 5671; and what I found necessary in publishing this tract is on account of three things: 1) to open an opening like the eye of a needle before the community of scholars, who, because they do not occupy themselves with this matter, since it is not in practice now, and because the books that speak of this matter are not to be found with everyone — that the scholars may come and deliberate upon this, whereby, with Yahweh's help, we shall through this merit to reach the desired goal. 2) To set down on paper some novel interpretations which I have newly derived in this matter, with the help of Him who graciously grants man knowledge. 3) In the substance of the proposal which I propose, with Yahweh's help, in such a manner that it shall be agreed in certain matters even according to the view of those who dispute, as I shall explain with Yahweh's help. It is stated in Tractate Sanhedrin, folio 13b: It was taught: ordination and the ordination of elders are by three. What is ordination and what is the ordination of elders? Rabbi Yohanan said: the ordaining of elders etc. Rav Aha the son of Rava said to Rav Ashi: Do they ordain him with the hand literally? He said to him: They ordain him by name: they call him "Rabbi" and give him authority to judge cases of fines etc. And this is the language of Maimonides of blessed memory in the Commentary on the Mishnah to Tractate Sanhedrin, chapter 1: And it seems to me that when there is agreement of all the sages and the students to set over them a man of the academy and to make him head — provided that this is in the Land of Israel, as we have mentioned — behold, for that man the academy is established, and he will be ordained, and he will afterwards ordain whomever he wishes; for if you do not say so, it is impossible that you should ever find the Great Court, since we shall need each one of them to be ordained in any case; and the Holy One, blessed be He, has promised that they shall return, as it is said: "And I will restore thy judges as at the first, and thy counsellors as at the beginning; afterward thou shalt be called the city of righteousness." And this will be, without doubt, when the Creator, blessed be He, prepares the hearts of men, and their merit and their longing for Yahweh, blessed be He, and for the Torah increase, and their wisdom grows great, before the coming of the Messiah, as this is made clear in many verses in Scripture; thus far his words. And this is the language of our master Maimonides of blessed memory in the Laws of the Sanhedrin, chapter 4, halakhah 11: It seems to me that if all the sages in the Land of Israel agreed to appoint judges and to ordain them, these are ordained, and they may judge cases of fines and may ordain others. If so, why were the sages distressed over ordination? So that cases of fines should not cease from Israel, because Israel are dispersed and it is impossible that they should all agree; and if there were there one ordained, he does not need the consent of them all but judges cases of fines for all. And the matter requires decision. Rabbi Ovadiah of Bertinoro, in the commentary on the Mishnah, brings the words of Maimonides from the Yad ha-Hazakah; and the Tosafot Yom Tov of blessed memory wrote that perhaps one may refute the proof which Maimonides brought in the Commentary on the Mishnah from the verse "And I will restore thy judges etc.", for Yahweh, blessed be He, has promised: "Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet etc.", and behold, he is ordained

17