Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
132scan
of 139
Facsimile · scan 132 of 139
Scan of scan 132
English · AI translation, checked against the Hebrew

Mount Tzvi

…of the House; and I found in the book Sedei Hemed (the section of the letter Vav, principle 26, paragraph 33) that there is in this the neglect of the positive commandment of sending away the impure, and so the Birkei Yosef concluded for prohibition; and he took issue with him: how is it possible that there should be a prohibition in this, since an idolater has no impurity whatever while he is alive? Thus far. And in my humble opinion, if it is on account of this, there is no proof; for granted that idolaters are not susceptible to receiving impurity, yet his garments are impure, and it is forbidden to bring an impure vessel into the Sanctuary, as is explained (Eruvin 104) and in Maimonides. And see the Sifre, portion Naso, which expounds "from male to female you shall send out" to include the minor as well; and seemingly a minor is not subject to the commandments; and I found that the book Hikekei Lev raised this point and wrote that the positive commandment of sending away the impure is a commandment upon the court and all Israel, and therefore we were warned also about sending away a minor who has become impure. And according to this, in our case too, one who sends a gentile to the Temple Mount transgresses this positive commandment of sending away the impure, since the law of one who brings in an impure vessel is also expounded from this very verse, "from male and to female you shall send out"; and there is much to enlarge on this, but this is not the place.

All this I have said in order to set it before the Rabbis and their disciples; and I hope that every upright student will find in them words of delight, and there will be fulfilled in him "Give to a wise man and he will be yet wiser"; and this will be my reward

Tzvi Pesach, son of my lord father, the Rabbi distinguished in Torah and the fear of Heaven etc., our teacher Rabbi Yehudah Leib Frank, of blessed memory

Tract: The Ordination of Elders.

Our Sages of blessed memory said: "Do not hold any thing to be remote" etc. These thousands of years that have passed over us in the course of the time of the Exile, many essentials of the Torah we have occupied ourselves with only to expound them and receive reward, and they were reckoned by us as "a halakhah for the Messiah". However, the political change in the present time has brought us to see that for some such laws the time has already come for them to be fulfilled in deed, and not only in study alone.

The matter of ordination, which has been in abeyance for nearly two thousand years — we can now say that we have been privileged to reach such a time that the study of it is for the sake of practice. Blessed be Yahweh, who has kept us alive and sustained us and brought us to a time when all the nations have recognised us as an ancient people, from whose ancient Torah, given by the Ancient of Days, from this well of living waters, all the children of the world have drunk. All of them have recognised that it is fitting for us (again) to return to the land of our fathers and to take hold in it; and we, for our part, what is incumbent upon us to do? To restore the crown of the glory of our pride as of old. All that is possible according to the Torah and according to what is possible, if indeed our hope has already come to return to the land of our fathers and take hold in it, so that our existence may be strong and enduring, and that we may be bound with cords of love to the Torah and religion, which are our life and the length of our days. We must renew the matter of ordination as in days of old, and seat a Great Assembly, a Great Sanhedrin, in Jerusalem the holy city, who shall give light to the earth and to those who dwell upon it, who shall be a "Tel Talpiyot", so that all mouths shall turn to them in every matter of Torah and of the upholding of religion. Through the founding of a Great Sanhedrin in Jerusalem the holy city, all