Mount Tzvi
…13) that sacrilege applies to growths there is a prohibition of the Torah, but even according to the one who says there that sacrilege does not apply to growths, nevertheless it is forbidden by rabbinic law. But to this one might answer somewhat that on the whole Temple Mount, which was a place of entry and sitting for everyone, the ground does not fall under a prohibition of benefit so as to forbid what comes forth from it; only the place of the Court and the Holy of Holies is to be reckoned a place forbidden for benefit. And although in the Court too there was a place of entry for all Israel, and especially for the priests, who used to eat there, nevertheless it is plain that the law of complete consecrated property rests upon it, and it was not permitted for benefit to the priests and to Israel except only for the needs of the Most High; and as with the priestly garments, which were given for benefit, yet when they wore out sacrilege applies to them; evidently they remain in their sanctity in every respect. And perhaps this is the reason for the view of Rashi as in Tosafot, Menahot page 21b, at the heading "Hullin", on what the master said, "they shall eat": that they may eat unconsecrated food with it. And the Kuntres explained: that is to say, outside the Court they may eat unconsecrated food and heave-offering; thus far. And one may say that this is the reason it is forbidden to eat unconsecrated food in the Court: because it is forbidden for benefit. And all the more so the Sanctuary, of which only sitting in its shade was permitted, as we say (Pesahim 26): "The Sanctuary is different, for it is made for its interior"; but in the case of something else it is forbidden. And if we say that the Temple Mount has no law of prohibition of benefit, then, according to the one who says that sacrilege does not apply to growths, it is only a rabbinic doubt, since the place of the growths is not exactly known. And one cannot raise a difficulty from the words of the Shakh, Yoreh De'ah 368, who forbids a tree planted on a place that is a doubtful grave; for one may say that there it is different, since according to the view of Ri (cited in the Rema there) the place of a grave is forbidden by the Torah, whereas in our case, according to the one who says that sacrilege does not apply to growths, it is only rabbinic (besides which one may say that regarding a grave, which is only on account of the honour of the dead, we ought to be stringent in its doubt, since even in a doubt there is disrespect to them, as it appears to the eye as though it stood upon the grave, and this doubt becomes as a certainty). Yet nevertheless, for our part, Maimonides has already ruled that sacrilege applies to growths, and if so, here too there is a prohibition of the Torah, so that one must be stringent even in its doubt; and all the more so since there is room to argue that it is certainly consecrated property. And as for its having been permitted for benefit even not for the needs of the Most High, one may say that this was only at the time of the Temple: since it was a place of entry for all Israel for the needs of the Service, it was also permitted not for that need, for the Torah was not given to the ministering angels; but at a time when the Temple does not stand, and even at the time of the Temple, a benefit such as this, of sowing and planting, the like of which does not exist for the needs of the Most High, was not permitted at all. And it is no less than the stones of Jerusalem that fell out, according to the one who says that Jerusalem was sanctified, that sacrilege applies to them, as is stated in Kiddushin 54; for although every benefit of the wall was permitted while it stood built upon its mound, nevertheless if one took of the stones of the wall to build them into his house he committed sacrilege; and if so, all the more so the Temple Mount, which has an added holiness, so that one may say that in this respect it has the law of complete consecrated property, to forbid the growths like the law of the growths of consecrated property. However, there is room to argue for permitting these growths on the ground that it is a case of "this and that cause". And although we hold that sacrilege applies to growths, that is where one consecrated a field with trees planted in it, for in that case, as regards its fruits, both causes are consecrated; which is not so in our case: these trees planted in a consecrated place are unconsecrated, for the gentiles planted them, and so it is a case of "this and that cause", the cause of the ground being consecrated and the cause of the tree being unconsecrated; and we hold that "this and that cause" is permitted. And in a similar vein the Mar'eh ha-Panim wrote, distinguishing, in his answer to those two mishnayot that seemed to him to contradict one another: for in Me'ilah we learned, "If one consecrated a tree and afterwards it filled with fruit", according to the words of Rabbi Judah, whom we follow, sacrilege applies to the growths; whereas in chapter 9 of Terumot we learned, "The growths of consecrated property and of second tithe are unconsecrated". And on this he answered, at the end of chapter 7 of Pe'ah, and these are his words: "And the reason of the matter appears to be that there
