61
Mount Tzvi
…we derive from the verse in which it is written, "and they offered burnt-offerings"; and in that very offering it is written there, "and he built an altar under the mount"; and if so, the building of the altar is also a positive commandment that preceded the Utterance, and we may well derive it from circumcision, the Passover offering and the daily offering, which override the Sabbath; thus far the substance of his words. But his words are not compelling, for Tosafot (Yevamot 5b) asked: "And if you say, let us derive it from the other sacrifices, which override the Sabbath, etc.; and Ri said that there all of them are counted as frequent, since they occur every year, and one can refute from circumcision and the other sacrifices, in that they are frequent"; thus far their words. And according to this the building of the altar cannot be derived from them, for one can refute: in that they are frequent. And with this I thought to resolve the difficulty of the Tiferet Yisrael (Yoma, chapter 6, mishnah 5) from the passage which derives the Service even in impurity, where he wonders: if so, we find that a positive commandment overrides a negative commandment that carries karet; see there, for his answer is very astonishing, since in truth the Talmud in Yevamot raises the objection from the daily offering and likewise from levirate marriage. If so, from the very place it comes from there is a contradiction to his words, for even in such a case, where the Torah said explicitly that it should be done so, it falls under the rule that a positive commandment overrides a negative commandment; but as to the substance of his difficulty one may say, as above, that this cannot be derived from it, because one can refute: in that it is frequent. And see the Shulhan Arukh, Orah Hayyim (section 180, paragraph 5): "It is the custom to cover the knife at the time of the Grace after Meals, and they were accustomed not to cover it on the Sabbath and festival"; and on this the Magen Avraham wrote there that the reason is because the table is like the altar, and of the altar it is written, "you shall not wield iron over them", and on the Sabbath one does not build an altar, so there is no allusion to the altar. Thus it is stated explicitly that there is no building of the altar on the Sabbath nor on a festival. And by the way I thought to bring from here support for what is written in the book Arukh la-Ner (Sukkah 41a), on what we say, that the Temple is not built at night: that this applies only to the building of the Sanctuary itself, but the altar may well be built at night; thus far. And at first sight this proves his words, for otherwise why do we cover the knife at night, according to what the Magen Avraham wrote, that at a time when it is not fit to be built there is no need to cover the knife; and this is not the place to enlarge on it. And to the Turei Even on Hagigah (6a) it is obvious that the building of the altar does not override a festival; and in the words of the Gaon Rabbi David Friedmann, of blessed memory, an explicit passage of the Jerusalem Talmud is cited, in the chapter "Rabbi Eliezer" on circumcision and in Pesahim, chapter "Elu Devarim", and these are its words: "They objected: but what of an altar that fell on the Sabbath? (meaning: and why does it not override the Sabbath?) And it answers: the altar was fit to be built from the day before"; and therefore, according to the Rabbis who dispute Rabbi Eliezer, it falls under the preparatory acts that do not override the Sabbath.
But in general I am astonished at the words of Maharia mentioned above: why need he bring from afar that in such a case a positive commandment overrides a negative commandment that carries karet, because it is a positive commandment that preceded the Utterance; and also, why need he make it depend on the Sabbath? For there is an explicit baraita (Eruvin 105a), and Maimonides too ruled it, that for the purpose of building it is permitted to enter the Holy of Holies even in impurity; and if so, for the purpose of building the altar it is certainly permitted to enter, even if we say that it does not override the Sabbath. And see Maimonides at the end of (chapter 7 of the Laws of the Chosen House, halakhah 23.
The Growths of the Temple Mount.
I was asked concerning the olives that grow on the Temple Mount, the place of our Sanctuary, which lies desolate because of our many sins; and the gentiles gather the olives there and bring them to sell in the markets of Jerusalem, may it be speedily rebuilt; and the questioner was in doubt, as a matter of practical halakhah, whether these olives are permitted to be eaten by a son of Israel. Now at first glance it would seem that it need not be said that according to the one who says (Me'ilah