Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
119scan
of 139

Mount Tzvi 60

…standing to be cleared away, then it is nullified to the natural ground, and then it is not like roofs and upper chambers. And the difficulty against him returns to its place, that he ought to have forbidden standing close to the Western Wall. But as regards this, one may somewhat strengthen the words of the Ridbaz of blessed memory, and at least keep half in our hands, and say that indeed it does not count as earth that is due to be cleared away, and nevertheless it is like roofs and upper chambers which were not sanctified; for at any rate, since it was not sanctified up to the height of the firmament, there is then no difference between the roof of a house and a place which they filled with earth, and we do not say that the nullification of the earth causes the sanctity to return to that height which is above the earth. But even on this approach there stands against us the second answer of Rabad and the responsum of the Radbaz mentioned above, according to whose words roofs and upper chambers newly made now, which did not exist in the time of the Temple, are not removed from their sanctity. Now at first sight one could prove that Tosafot disagree with this reasoning, from what they asked in Makkot (12a) about the tree which stood outside and leaned inward: since roofs and upper chambers were not sanctified, then one may not eat second tithe upon the tree. And according to the reasoning of Rabad and the Radbaz mentioned above there is no room for their difficulty, for roofs and upper chambers themselves which were built after the place had already been sanctified did not lose their sanctity; and if so, this tree too, which was planted after Jerusalem had already been sanctified, no longer interposes before the sanctity. But in truth this is no difficulty, for Tosafot follow their own view, as Rabad himself cited in the name of Tosafot, that they did not come down to this distinction, but in every case roofs and upper chambers were not sanctified, even though they were made afterwards.

And after examination it appears further that Tosafot too hold like Rabad; for what they answered in the second answer, "or else, the airspace of Jerusalem is like Jerusalem," is hard to fit; and see what Maharsha and Maharam explained on this. Now at the words of Maharsha the Mishneh le-Melekh has already wondered (on chapter 11 of the Laws of Inadvertent Sins), for in the Talmud, Pesahim there, it is explained that in Jerusalem too we say that roofs and upper chambers were not sanctified. And the words of Maharam too are not understood: what is the difference between a tree and roofs and upper chambers? And further, the language of Tosafot does not show that they intended the distinction of Maharam. And therefore it seems to me that the answers of Tosafot here in Makkot proceed in another manner, like the words of Rabad there in Tamid: the first answer of Tosafot accords with the first answer of Rabad, that in any case roofs and upper chambers were not sanctified, even if they were built afterwards, after the place had already been sanctified; and the second answer of Tosafot is the second answer of Rabad. And to explain their words I shall first set out a short preface: that at first sight it appears that according to the first answer of Rabad, and likewise according to the first answer of Tosafot, one must necessarily say that the sanctity of the airspace of the Court, and likewise of the city, is necessarily not holy in its own right; and although the airspace of the Court is like the Court (Shevuot 17a), and likewise the airspace of Jerusalem is like Jerusalem, as for instance where the branches have not a breadth of four handbreadths and it is not a place of account in itself, nevertheless the root of the sanctity is the ground, and the sanctity breaks through and rises up to the firmament so long as there is nothing interposing; but if there is the interruption of a partition between it and the ground, it cuts off and interposes in the sanctity of the airspace that rises from below upward. Which is not so according to the second answer of Rabad, who came to distinguish between roofs built before the sanctity took effect and those built afterwards; and this must necessarily mean that according to this answer he holds that the sanctity of the airspace is in its own right: that just as they sanctified the pavement, so the airspace was sanctified by itself (as I cited above in the name of the Tohorat ha-Kodesh, that David sanctified the pavement and Solomon sanctified the airspace too); and then no interruption whatsoever avails