Mount Tzvi
…Yose the sanctification was not only for the sanctity of the Court alone, but in truth he sanctified it for the sake of the sanctity of the altar; only that it is not possible to offer except afterwards, on condition that he set up the altar on it; but the sanctity of the altar took effect on the place from the outset, through Solomon. And by this is resolved what I remarked, that above, on page 24, we say that David sanctified the pavement, whereas there is an explicit verse that Solomon sanctified the middle of the court; and likewise Rashi on Shevuot 2, that David and Solomon sanctified it. But by this it is well resolved: both of them sanctified it; David sanctified it with the sanctity of the Court, and Solomon added to sanctify it with the sanctity of the altar, for this counts as an addition of sanctity.
Now in the Responsa Beit Ridbaz, printed here in the Holy City, at the end of section 38, he was in doubt whether one who adds earth to the height of the Court, or adds building to the height of the altar, requires a new sanctification, each according to its own, like one who adds in breadth; or shall we say that the addition in height is sanctified of itself by the first sanctification of what is beneath it; see there well. And according to what I have written, this doubt of his can be resolved from that mishnah of tractate Middot, that when the children of the Exile came up they added to the altar; and according to the method of Rashi this would be difficult for the one who says that we learned "with all of these"; and one is forced to say, as above, that since the place had already been sanctified with the sanctity of the altar through Solomon, who sanctified the whole pavement, the addition in the height of the building no longer requires sanctification at all.
And passing from one matter to another, I said further concerning what Rashi wrote on Zevahim 24, that he sanctified it with two thank-offerings; and Tosafot objected against him from that passage in Shevuot, that the Court is sanctified only with the remainder of a meal-offering. And behold, in truth below (60a) Rashi himself wrote, "and its sanctification is with the remainder of a meal-offering"; and likewise on page (56a), concerning the chambers built on unconsecrated ground, he wrote, "that they were not sanctified with the sanctity of the Court with the remainder of a meal-offering" etc. And if so, the wonder grows: why did he change his method here, to write "with two thank-offerings"? And according to my humble opinion it would seem that the reason we require the remainder of a meal-offering is because we compare it to Jerusalem, where we require a thing that is disqualified by going out of it; and this reason applies in the days of Solomon, when the high places were forbidden, which is not so in the days of David, when the high places were permitted. If so, for the one who says that a meal-offering is offered on a high place, a meal-offering too is not disqualified by going out, and there is no difference between a meal-offering and a thank-offering. See Rashash (Menahot 25), who inclines to the view that there is no disqualification of going out even at a public high place, and therefore a meal-offering is not required at all; and on the matter of what Tosafot wrote concerning the sanctification of the Temple Mount, that a thing that is disqualified by going out of it is not required. But still, what Rashi wrote (Megillah 10a), "and they again sanctified it with thank-offerings and with song", is not resolved by this, for there it speaks of the Sanctuary, and the high places were forbidden. Therefore it seems, according to what Tosafot asked (Shevuot 15a): for the one who says there is no meal-offering at a high place, how did they sanctify it in the days of Solomon? And they answered in the second answer: "or else, since it is not possible, it is not required"; end. According to this one may say that for the one who says there is no meal-offering at a high place, in the days of David it was not possible to sanctify with a meal-offering; and likewise in that passage of Megillah Rashi rightly wrote "with thank-offerings", since it is impossible with a meal-offering for the one who says there is no meal-offering at a high place; which is not so on page 56 and likewise on page 60, where the altar had already been built in the Eternal House, and we require specifically a meal-offering. Afterwards I found in the book Rosh ha-Mizbeah that he anticipated me in some of my words; see there well. And this is not the place to enlarge on it.
In the book Hatan Sofer he wrote that either way one may offer in this time: if as Maimonides, then it is well; and if one may not offer in this time, there is no question of holy things outside, for we hold like Rabbi Shimon, that when one has not
