Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion and First to Zion · 1866
82scan
of 88

First to Zion

  1. On what I wrote to our master in section 3, concerning the priestly garments, in the matter of Arakhin 3: the Maharham, may his light shine, raised a difficulty against me, that the passage of Menahot 6 also says "mixed kinds were permitted for them", and it implies that it speaks of an ordinary priest, as Rashi wrote; see there. And afterwards he brought me support from the book Hiddushei ha-Meiri, and likewise from the Shittah Mekubbetzet on Betzah, and these are its words: "And some explain that it is not the priestly garments that are hard, but only the belts of an ordinary priest; but the breastplate and the ephod are soft and forbidden by the law of the Torah, and that is the passage at the beginning of Arakhin and Menahot," end of his words. And so the Ran wrote at the end of the first chapter of Betzah: here it is explicitly according to my approach. He also brought me the words of Maimonides and of Rabad at the end of the Laws of Mixed Kinds; and to me it seems that from the words of Rabad there is a clear proof for my words. For Maimonides wrote there that a priest who put on the belt not at the time of the Service is flogged, and Rabad wrote: "He erred in this, for in Yoma, chapter Ba Lo, we say that it is permitted not at the time of the Service"; and he concluded, these are his words: "And as for what he says, 'because of the belt, which is mixed kinds' — is it to be said that the breastplate and the ephod have no mixed kinds in them?" end of his words. And this is not understandable at all: how did he refute Maimonides by the fact that the breastplate and the ephod are also mixed kinds? And the Kesef Mishneh wrote: "I do not know how he wrote in this language" etc. But according to my approach the puzzling words of Rabad are well understood: he knew that Maimonides has a proof from this passage of Arakhin and Menahot that it is mixed kinds and forbidden to an ordinary priest; against this he says, what proof does Maimonides have from this, for is it to be said that the breastplate and the ephod have no mixed kinds in them? — and it is of these that this passage of Arakhin and Menahot speaks. And consider it carefully.

  2. And as for the point I pressed against Maimonides, who wrote that the blood of the chilazon (the shellfish of the blue dye) is found in the salt sea, whereas the Talmud says that it comes up once in seventy years, and I answered that in this there is a difference between the Land of Israel and outside the Land: on this the Maharham brought me the words of Radbaz, part 2, section 685, who wrote that in the portion of Zebulun it came up once in seventy years etc., and at the making of the Tabernacle they were near the Red Sea and hunted it from the Red Sea etc. And the Maharham raised a difficulty against him from the Jerusalem Talmud, Shabbat chapter 7, at the end of the halakhah: "What dyeing was there in the Tabernacle?" And the Korban ha-Edah asked why it does not say that they dyed tekhelet (the blue), and answered that they brought it with them from Egypt. And according to Radbaz the Korban ha-Edah's difficulty against the Jerusalem Talmud remains, for it should have said that they dyed tekhelet which they hunted from the Red Sea; and he dwelt on this at length. But in truth there is no great difficulty against Radbaz, if he holds with our Talmud, which disagrees with the Jerusalem Talmud, as we say in Shabbat 74 that for hunting, and also for tying and untying, one is liable only on account of the hunting of the chilazon; whereas the Jerusalem Talmud holds that there was no hunting in the Tabernacle, except, according to one opinion, of a beast, and according to another opinion one is wholly exempt for hunting; see there. And if so, Radbaz ruled


…but according to the one who says there is a meal-offering at a high place, it is no difficulty for them. If so, it is proven that Tosafot hold, against Rabbenu Hayyim, that they had the remnants of a meal-offering from a high place. And Rabbenu Hayyim himself, one may say, holds that it was sanctified for the time to come; but Rabad, if he holds as the halakhah that it was not sanctified, how is the sanctification of the Court from Ezra to be found? It must be that the high places are permitted.

And as for Tosafot's answer there, that everything came at once, the sanctification and the Court: this they wrote only according to Rabbi Judah; but our passage perforce does not hold so, since it says there on side b, "Does one alone sanctify?" and if it sanctified all at once there would be no difficulty at all; it must be that we do not say so. And likewise their answer, that where it is not possible it is not required, is also difficult: if so, where a king and the Urim and Thummim are lacking, let us also say that it is not possible. It must be that they wrote this only where the thing does not exist at all, even in the days of Solomon; but a king and the Urim and Thummim, which were possible in the days of Solomon, are indispensable today too. And if so, the difficulty returns to its place: whence did they have the remnants of a meal-offering? It must be as I have written. And although one could resolve it, with strain, that they hold one of all these suffices, this is not so, for if so Tosafot would have raised no difficulty at all; rather they certainly hold that according to everyone the remnants of a meal-offering are required, for otherwise why did Nehemiah need two thank-offerings, since he had one of all these without thank-offerings? And consider it carefully, for by this the difficulty of the Maharsha there is resolved. And the true Gaon of Grätz brought a proof that Tosafot in Shevuot do not hold with Rabbenu Hayyim, for they left it as a wonder in the comment beginning "Teni": "But several Mishnahs hold that it was sanctified, in Zevahim, that there is no permission after it." And what difficulty is that? For even if it was only not sanctified, there is nevertheless no permission after it. Rather, Tosafot there certainly do not hold with Rabbenu Hayyim.