Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion and First to Zion · 1866
79scan
of 88

First to Zion 41

  1. Some further correct remarks were written to me by the Rabbi, the great luminary, keen and erudite, our teacher Rabbi David Ziskind, may his light shine, mentioned above. 1) How can they bring the Passover offering? For men and women with a flux require a sacrifice, and one who still lacks atonement profanes the Service; and for women the first Passover is an obligation, since we hold with the Sages, and most women are impure with a flux; and when the minority of impurity and flux among the men is added, the majority of the community are afflicted with a flux, and they could perform it neither at the first nor at the second. Thus far his words. And I answered him on two sides. First: Maimonides ruled in chapter 7 of the Laws of the Passover Offering, halakhah 7: "How does one reckon for the Passover offering, to know whether it is a majority of the impure or of the pure? One does not reckon by all those who eat etc., but one reckons those who enter the Court etc."; see there. And this is from the Talmud, Pesahim 94. If so, the women do not enter the Court of the men, but send through the husband or through their father; and since they do not enter, they do not belong to the majority of the community, and there remain the men, most of whom are not afflicted with a flux. And so it is in the Jerusalem Talmud, chapter Kitzad Tzolin, halakhah 6, that women are not counted together for a ruling of the court; and it compares the Passover offering there to such a ruling, in that they are not included in the majority. If so, the view of the Gaonim who permitted the Passover offering at the present time works out well. And should you object: but he ruled there, halakhah 3, "If they were half and half, the women complete the majority" — yet they did not enter the Court! (and this difficulty is hard for the Talmud even without my approach) — in truth Maimonides guarded against this, for he wrote the reason for the matter, that one reckons by those who enter, because it is possible that twenty are registered for one Passover offering and they send it by the hand of one. If so, in half and half, if many women send to have it slaughtered on their behalf and the agent enters the Court, then one tips the half into a majority. And in our case, if there should be, for example, ten thousand men and ten thousand women, we shall instruct the women that twenty of them send one agent to the Court, and there remain of the ten thousand five hundred; and if so, the men, impure through the dead and not afflicted with a flux, are the majority. Second: it is not necessarily so that most of them have a flux, for many of them are at the outset menstruants, who were purified by immersion without a sacrifice and never came at all into the category of flux; only women after childbirth certainly lack atonement, and they are not the majority; or else the women after childbirth will proceed by the first answer. Consider it carefully.

  2. Second: in Yoma 7 and Pesahim 76 they supposed that in general impurity is overridden and we require the frontplate to make acceptable; it is proven from this that without the frontplate there is no acceptance; and since we have no frontplate at the present time, how can they offer the Passover offering in impurity? Thus far his words. And this is a correct difficulty; and it seems to me to resolve it thus. For I find it difficult regarding Rabbi Joshua and Rabbi Yose, how the Mishnah teaches, "The Passover offering is eaten in impurity", since they hold that the frontplate does not make acceptable for eatings; and why does he raise the objection only according to the one who says, "If there is no flesh there is no blood"? Even according to the one who says there is blood without flesh it is also difficult: how is it eaten without acceptance? And there is further the difficulty of Tosafot, at the words "That we have not found" etc.: "Ri finds it astonishing, for in our passage


…Tractate Middot, and these are his words: "He placed Middot after Tamid, and it has no other matter but a narrative in which he records the measurement of the Sanctuary and its form and its building; and the benefit there is in that matter is that when it is built, speedily in our days, one must keep and make that pattern, and the patterns and the forms and the proportions, because it is by the holy spirit, as it is written: 'All is by the hand of Yahweh, He made me understand.'" Thus far his words. And if it were as some understand, that only a Sanctuary of fire will come from heaven, there is no benefit at all in the whole tractate Middot, of which Maimonides said that it is for benefit when it is built, speedily in our days, that we make it after its pattern and its form. Rather it is clear beyond doubt that it will be made by human hands, and afterwards the Sanctuary on high will come upon it or into it, after the coming of the son of David. And so the Gaon, the Tosafot Yom Tov, concluded there, and these are his words: "And so we too, when we merit to build the future building, the Holy One, blessed be He, will open our eyes to understand what is hidden in Ezekiel, and we shall build it etc.; and had this narrative not been written in a book, we would not have found our hands and our feet in that future building which will be built speedily in our days." Thus far his words. So it was plain to all of them that it will be built speedily in our days by our hands, and will not descend suddenly from heaven.