36
Essay on Holy Things
…the redemption of Israel. Happy is he who has merited such an understanding, and perhaps through him the fear of Yahweh will shine forth upon the congregation of Israel, and they will say, "Come, let us entreat the kings of the earth", preceded by prayer to Yahweh, as Nehemiah did; and this will be for the prosperity of all the kings and all the peoples, for now there is no perfection of good in the world, and then it will be as Yahweh willed at the beginning of the Creation. End of his words. And these are the disputations in brief: 1) On what I wrote in my reply to our master Akiva, section 5, to resolve the difficulty of Tosafot, "Did Rabbi Yitzhak not know the Mishnah?", and I meant that he relied on the Mishnah of Shevuot, reading "with one of all these" etc.; to this the Gaon, our teacher Rabbi Eliyahu mentioned above, replied that even one who reads "with one of all these" can hold that it was sanctified for the time to come; and since that is so, there is a difficulty against Rabad, who ruled that it was not sanctified: what will he answer to the two Mishnahs that are cited in Shevuot? Hence he must hold like Rabbi Hayyim, that even if it was not sanctified the high places are forbidden; and if so, according to Rabad, who holds like Rabbi Hayyim, there is no permission at the present time. And granted that in law one should rule like Maimonides and the majority of the decisors, that it was sanctified for the time to come, and consequently it is permitted at the present time; nevertheless, according to Rabad it is not permitted. Thus far from his lengthy words. And I replied to him: for according to the view of Rabbi Hayyim the first difficulty of Tosafot in Megillah is still not resolved, "Did Rabbi Yitzhak not know the Mishnah?"; but according to my approach it is well. For there is a difficulty: how can we say, according to Rabbi Nahman, that "with one of all these" is what we learned, when it is written "and so shall you make", from which the Talmud in Shevuot derives that for future generations all these are required? So we must say that this Tanna holds that it was not sanctified for the time to come; and then it is proved from the fact that Ezra certainly sanctified it, that since Scripture disclosed "them" by anointing with regard to the vessels, the place of the Sanctuary is consequently also excluded, so that all these are not required. But if he held that it was sanctified for the time to come, then there is no difficulty from the verse "and so shall you make", for one may say that this holds only until Solomon, but from Solomon onward it is not required at all; and so Rabbi Yitzhak held at the end, when he retracted on account of the contradiction from Abba Shaul; but in our passage he proved it well from the Mishnah, as I have written. And I further wrote to him that the main approach of Rabbi Hayyim was proved to him from the difficulty of Tosafot, why he retracted; and according to the approach of Maimonides there is no difficulty at all even without this, for these Tannaim speak only of the sanctities of the Land of Israel, but as for the sanctity of the altar one may say that all hold it was sanctified, and there is no dispute among the Tannaim; and since the difficulty of Rabbi Hayyim falls away, we consequently hold according to the plain sense, as is the view of Rashi in Zevahim 119, that the high places are permitted according to the one who says it was not sanctified; Tosafot too did not decide at all whether like Rashi or like Rabbi Hayyim. And as his Eminence, the Gaon, may his light shine, also wrote, in Shevuot it is proved that they do not hold like Rabbi Hayyim, since they raised a difficulty against Rabbi Nahman from these Mishnahs; if so, this is not like Rabbi Hayyim. And as for what he wrote, that if Rabad does not hold like Rabbi Hayyim, what will he say to these Mishnahs from which the difficulty is raised against Rabbi Yitzhak: there is no difficulty, for several Tannaim hold that it was not sanctified, as is cited in Tosafot to Zevahim 61; and also that ruling of "they shall rot" is proved from an anonymous passage of the Talmud. 2) Further the Gaon, our teacher Rabbi Eliyahu, may his light shine, wrote, and these are his words: "What his Eminence wrote, that the impediment of impurity does not apply on account of the community, he wrote well, and all the communal sacrifices were permitted without distinction; and he rightly rejected also the words of the Gaon of Pressburg, of blessed memory. And there is something to raise in this matter (for it is always better if we raise it ourselves, and do not wait until another cries out and says that we did not know of this): it is possible that, since there is no way to offer on the Day of Atonement, for there is no High Priest, and there are no garments of the High Priest, and there is no shamir for the stones, and there is also no knowledge of the stones; and since it is impossible to offer on the Day of Atonement, whether they are permitted to offer all the year; how can they be called daily offerings if they are not offered daily? etc. And all this is only a note, lest they come to doubt." Thus far from his words. And I replied that his words are just in this, that we must satisfy those who doubt, although he himself does not determine it as true; but in my humble opinion there is not even the beginning of a doubt in this. For when they had no lambs for some time in the days of Aristobulus (as is mentioned in the Talmud), did they afterwards stop offering in that year when lambs arrived? And likewise in the days of the Greeks, when the Hasmoneans defeated them at Hanukkah, did they not offer because they had ceased on the Day of Atonement and at some time or other? Rather, it is certain that this is no ground for doubt
