Essay on the Service 26
…that, Elijah will come at the end and completion of the redemption, before the coming of the great and terrible day; and therefore there will be great need of the law given to Moses at Sinai mentioned above. For when an altar is built before Elijah comes, we would not know how to make a sweet savour to Yahweh, because we would wait for the prophet to make known to us who is fit to serve as priest and to offer a sacrifice to Yahweh; and when there is no sacrifice for atonement and for acceptance before Yahweh, the light of prophecy, which comes after the sacrifice, will not appear, as it was in the First Temple, where upon the offering of the sacrifice the cloud filled the holy place, and so it was in the days of consecration of the Tabernacle in the wilderness; and as I brought above from the Sifre, that we are not to wait for a prophet but only to seek Zion, and afterwards a prophet will come; and as with Manoah, where He did wondrously through the sacrifice. And if we should then wait for the purity of the priests through a prophet, there will be no sacrifice, and if so the beginning of the redemption will be almost among the impossible things, Heaven forbid: for there is no sacrifice without Elijah, on account of the priests, and no Elijah without a sacrifice. For this reason the One great in counsel prepared the healing remedy beforehand, to make known to us through a law given to Moses at Sinai that we are not to wait for Elijah on account of the purity of the priests; for all the priests will be in the presumption of their fitness in the future, and Elijah does not come to bring near or to put away. Rather, everyone who traces his descent from his fathers under the name of priest, and in whom no flaw is found, we follow the majority and the presumption, since it is not possible to clarify the matter by a written genealogy; and Elijah comes only to bring near one of whom a taint of disqualification was heard and whom we put away out of doubt, or whom they put away by force and by the strength of their hand, not according to law, as the sons of Zion did to a certain family; or the reverse, one who ought to be disqualified out of doubt and whom its friends brought near by force: concerning such as these Elijah will make known the truth, since it was not by the law of the Torah that it was declared fit. But one who was declared fit according to the law of the Torah, for instance where they relied on the presumptions and we declared it fit, then even if in truth there is a taint of disqualification in it, Elijah will not put it away, because the law of the Torah declared it fit, and the act of a court done according to law stands for ever. And Rabbi Judah added that even those who were brought near not according to law Elijah will not put away; rather, everyone who is called by the name of priest from his fathers, without a clarified flaw, shall minister with his brethren the priests. And so Maimonides wrote in his Commentary on the Mishnah mentioned above, and these are his words: "And the Sages say there is no wrong done in matters of lineage; everyone who is called by his name, all will be traced to the truth, and the Torah, which is a father to all", end of his words. And this is not intelligible except according to our way mentioned above: that whoever the law of the Torah permitted on the basis of majority and presumption is called by his name and is traced to the truth, even though it may possibly be contrary to the truth; the Torah forbade the disqualified, and it declared fit by means of majority and presumption and the other statutes of our holy Torah. And now go forth and learn: if one who was brought near not according to law Elijah will not put away, all the more so one in whom no flaw at all is known, that he remains in the presumption of his fitness.
- And if someone should answer me from the words of the Talmud (chapter 2 of Ketubot, folio 23), where they dispute whether one may raise from heave-offering to lineage, and from this verse: "These sought their register of genealogy and did not find it, and they were defiled from the priesthood" (Ezra 4), to this I will give my answer on two grounds: 1) that in the time of the Second Temple most of the priests had a written genealogy, and one may not rely on the majority where it is possible to clarify by a written genealogy, which he ought to have kept like all his brethren the priests; and there is also in him the flaw of a lapse, in that the written genealogy was lost from it, and he must bring proof. 2) that at that time there was a clear flaw, as Rashi explained (Ketubot 24) at the heading "sought their register": because priests in the exile intermarried with the peoples of the land and had sons born to them, as is written in the book of Ezra, and these are profaned; therefore those born in the exile needed to establish their lineage when they went up
