Essay on Holy Things 12
…the Rabbi, etc., our teacher Rabbi Henikh, may his light shine, Segal. And as to the substance of the matter, I do not agree; for even before our hands reach to deciding the dispute of the great authorities, Maimonides and Rabad, chapter 6, halakhah 14 of the Laws of the Chosen House, and likewise to deciding on the place of the altar and the measurements of the altar itself by handbreadths of four of our middling thumb-breadths, which is very difficult, whether to be liberal with ample measures in generous cubits, or perhaps, since "all is in writing from the hand of Yahweh, He gave understanding", there stands before us a hard mountain in the matter of the priesthood. For in the Responsa of Rashdam, part Even ha-Ezer, section 235, after discussing at length a captive woman attested by hearsay testimony, whether she is permitted to a priest, he concluded: and if one relies on what Ribash wrote in a responsum, section 34 (in the case of a captive woman and a priest), these are his words: "All the more so the priests of our generation, who have no written genealogy; but only for the sake of good order is it customary today to call them to the Torah first as priests." So the priests at this time going up first is nothing but a mere custom, since they have no book of genealogy; learn from this that they are not complete and certain priests but doubtful ones. And afterwards, since the prohibition of a captive woman is only a Rabbinic prohibition, it is enough for us to be stringent in what is certainly forbidden; but in a matter of doubt it is proper to say that a doubt in Rabbinic law is resolved leniently. And further, it is a double doubt: perhaps she was defiled, perhaps he is not a priest. End of his words. And in my feeble and humble opinion, this is correct, to prove from the words of Ribash that they are priests by doubt; but as to what Rashdam wrote, that being called to the Torah first is only a mere custom, and as he also wrote, "it is enough for us to be stringent in what is a certain prohibition", which implies that this too is only by way of stringency, in my humble opinion, begging your honour's pardon, it is not so; since in any case they stand in the presumption of priests, they have not left the category of doubt, and are forbidden by strict law in the prohibitions of the priesthood as certain priests. And likewise it is by way of obligation that they are called first, out of the doubt that perhaps they are priests, and we are obliged to fulfil with them the positive commandment "And thou shalt sanctify him". And what Ribash wrote, "it is customary", means that it became customary according to the law; for they go up to the priestly blessing, where mere stringency does not apply, since if they are not priests they transgress a positive commandment (see Magen Avraham, beginning of section 128). And in the Responsa Hut ha-Shani, at the end of the section, he wrote, and these are his words: "And we read in the chapter Ha-Ishah Rabbah: Whence do we know that if he does not wish, we compel him? Scripture says, And thou shalt sanctify him. And there is no distinction in this from the earlier ones, who had a written genealogy, except as regards permitting them something forbidden to non-priests; but as regards forbidding them anything forbidden to priests, there is no distinction." End of his words. And this is contrary to Rashdam mentioned above. Nevertheless this is only so as not to permit them anything forbidden to priests; but nevertheless, to permit them anything forbidden to non-priests, there is a distinction between the earlier generations and the priests of our time; as indeed in my humble opinion it stands to reason that one is not to be lenient for them in any matter of the Rabbinic disqualifications of the priesthood, since they have been presumed to be priests. And indeed Ribash himself wrote in section 348 forbidding to a priest a woman divorced by Rabbinic law, and the implication is that this is so for the priests of our time. But nevertheless, that is to say, according to the opinion of Hut ha-Shani, one is to be stringent and not permit them anything forbidden to non-priests; and as for their raising their hands in the priestly blessing, one must say: since they have been presumed for this, they have been presumed; or, since in the reverse case too, in neglecting the priestly blessing, they likewise transgress a positive commandment (except that nevertheless it would have been proper to rule that they are not to be called to go up, and then there would be no positive commandment). Maharit too, in Part, section 149, decides everything so as not to be lenient for them in anything forbidden to certain priests. Afterwards I found the matter exactly as it stands in the Rabbi, our teacher Rabbi Shmuel Yafeh, in his book Yefeh Mar'eh on the aggadot of the Jerusalem Talmud, who wrote on Berakhot, chapter 8, halakhah 2, at the words "He who makes use of the priesthood commits sacrilege", and these are his words: "That people are not careful about this now, one may judge them favourably, since there is now no priest of certain lineage, and many of them are counterfeit, as Ribash wrote, section 34. But nevertheless no priest may be lenient in any prohibition of the priesthood; for since he holds himself to be a priest, he must observe all the strict laws of the priesthood, for we follow presumption to be stringent. And I had to write this because I saw one who wrote that we should learn from the words of Ribash mentioned above to be lenient for a priest in a Rabbinic prohibition of the priesthood; and that is not so, for Ribash himself was stringent in section 348 even in Rabbinic heave-offering for the priest of his day." End of his words. So it is as we have said, that one is not to be lenient for them in any matter forbidden to a priest, for we follow presumption to be stringent; nevertheless it is clear from the opinion of Maharash that for leniency, to permit them what is forbidden to non-priests, we do not judge them as certain priests. And so wrote Mahariv, cited in the gloss on the Shulhan Arukh, Orah Hayyim, section 457: "And some say that at this time one does not give hallah to any priest to eat." And so Rashal copied it as the law in Yam shel Shlomo, beginning of chapter 8 of Hullin, section 4, for the reason that they now have no written genealogy. And further still, Rashal wrote in Yam shel Shlomo, chapter 5 of Bava Kamma, section 35, and these are his words: "It seems that one ought to be stringent and forbid devoted things at this time, even if he designated it for a priest and the priest has already received it,