Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion · 1862
23scan
of 43

11 Essay on the Service

…and one may not rely on the majority where it is possible to clarify by means of the written genealogy, which he ought to have kept like all his brethren the priests; and there is moreover in him the flaw of a loss, in that his written genealogy was lost from him, and it is upon him to bring proof. 2) That then there was a clear flaw, as Rashi explained on Ketubot 24, s.v. "they sought their register": "Because priests in the Exile intermarried with the peoples of the land and bore sons to them, as is written in the book of Ezra, and these are profaned. Therefore those born in the Exile needed to establish their lineage when they came up from the Exile to minister in the building of the Second Temple." End of Rashi's words. Thus it is explicit that only because of the flaw did they need to establish their lineage; but had there been no flaw, they would have relied on the presumption, for great is presumption. And for this reason, what the Talmud says there, that he permitted them only the holy things of the provinces, in which they had been presumed, and not heave-offering by Torah law, that refers to that time when there was the flaw mentioned above, as Rashi explains; but now, since they had already been clarified and made clean in the time of the Temple by the court sitting in the Chamber of Hewn Stone to examine the priesthood, as stated in the Talmud, and whoever did not bring proof was put out of the priesthood, it follows that all who remained there under the name of priests are in their presumption, without a flaw.

And if one should further answer me from the words of Maimonides, chapter 20 of the Laws of Forbidden Intercourse: "All priests at this time are priests by presumption and eat only the holy things of the provinces; but heave-offering by Torah law is eaten only by a priest of attested lineage. And who is of attested lineage? Anyone concerning whom two witnesses testified that he is a priest, son of so-and-so the priest, up to a man who needs no examination, and that is the priest who ministered upon the altar." End of his words. And if for heave-offering by Torah law we require attested lineage at this time, how much more for the weightier Service? There are many replies to the matter. Surely in this matter of the strength of lineage of which he wrote, the source flows from the Talmud, Kiddushin folio 76: "One does not examine from the altar upward"; and as the Rabbi the Maggid wrote there, that the chief examination in the Mishnah is of four mothers, which are eight; and the Talmud asks, "Let us examine among the men," and answers it; and it is proved from there that if a man required examination, they would require four mothers for him and no more, but not examination up to a priest who ministered; for every priest who was examined in four mothers, that is, in four generations, is in his presumption. And so it is explicitly in Tosafot there. And Rabbenu Tam wrote in Sefer ha-Yashar that where examination is needed, that is only to make their sons fit for the Service, or else to make himself fit for the Service; but to let him eat heave-offering no examination is needed, as we say in the chapter "The Woman": "I am a priest and my fellow is a priest" is believed to let him eat heave-offering, but not to marry him to a woman. End of his words. Thus he holds that to make himself fit for the Service this examination of four mothers also suffices, for that is what is treated there; and the Talmud took only the lenient side, "One does not examine from the altar upward," that if his grandfather ministered at the altar this examination is not needed. And if so, it is difficult regarding Maimonides: why did he take it stringently? To this it seems that the intention of Maimonides there is like Rabbenu Tam mentioned above, and he asked: who is of attested lineage without examination of four mothers? If we know of him that he ministered upon the altar, then there is no further need to examine his mothers; but examination certainly suffices, and this examination is possible to carry out even today. And if you say: surely Maimonides stated his words without qualification? It may be said that for this reason he wrote in his language, "up to a man who needs no examination, etc.; therefore one does not examine, etc.," which implies explicitly that without this lineage of the altar one does examine; and that is the examination which Maimonides mentioned in chapter 19, halakhah 18 there. The second reply to the difficulty from the words of Maimonides mentioned above: behold, by the Torah we certainly follow majority and presumption, as we proved clearly above from the words of Rashi, and as we say in the Talmud, "All lands are in the presumption of fitness"; only that, as an added stringency, they made an enactment, and only where it is possible with men of attested lineage; but where it is impossible, there being not a single priest of attested lineage, shall they uproot a Service ordained by the Torah for the sake of a rabbinic stringency? And although the Sages have power to uproot a positive commandment of the Torah for the sake of a decree, that is when it is occasional, as for instance not to blow the shofar on a New Year that falls on the Sabbath, where it is uprooted only in that year; but wherever the commandment would be uprooted forever, no; and so the Magen Avraham wrote, section 589, sub-section 4, see there. And if so, when the Service is possible, how could it be uprooted for the sake of a stringency? And the obligation of the commandment of the Service has not been annulled from among us; wherever there is leave and possibility to offer, the duty lies upon the whole of Israel as of old. Third reply: Maimonides wrote explicitly in the Commentary on the Mishnah, Kiddushin, on the Mishnah "One who marries a woman who is a priest's daughter must examine after her"; these are his words at the end of his remarks there: "And all this is required in a family against which a protest has been raised, that is, that they say, 'In such-and-such a family there is disqualification'; but a family in which there is no suspicion must be examined, for the principle with us is that all families stand in the presumption of fitness." End of his words. And so the Rabbi wrote on chapter 4 of Kiddushin. And behold, concerning this examination we have learned: "One does not examine from