Essay on the Service
…Zakkai, who heard from his teacher, and his teacher from his teacher, as a law given to Moses at Sinai, that Elijah does not come to declare impure or pure, to bring near or to push away, but to bring near those who were pushed away by force and to push away those who were brought near by force. The family of Beit Tzerifah was beyond the Jordan, and the sons of Zion pushed it away by force; and another family was there, and the sons of Zion brought it near by force: such as these Elijah comes to push away and to bring near. Rabbi Judah says: to bring near, but not to push away. And the Ra'av of blessed memory explained that Elijah does not come to clarify the doubt of the families, which one was absorbed, but will leave them, and they are fit in the time to come, etc.; but a family that was absorbed because its disqualification was not known, he will leave in its fitness. End of his words. From this we learn that every doubt in a family stands in the presumption of fitness for the future, so long as no flaw is known in them. And there are several difficulties in this saying: 1) Is it then a halakhah for the days of the Messiah? (as the Talmud objects several times). Why should a law given to Moses at Sinai come about the thing that Elijah will do? Surely when Elijah comes he will know what he is to do, and for us there is no practical consequence, only for Elijah? 2) It is difficult: surely the truth was known from Sinai, that in the future the book of genealogies would cease and no men of attested lineage would be found, and therefore Elijah will be needed to clarify which are priests of attested lineage and to inform us, "This one is a fit priest and worthy to offer"; how then can we say, as a law given to Moses at Sinai, that he does not come to bring near and to push away, so as to know who shall offer and who shall hold back and be put out of the priesthood as unfit? And if, apart from Elijah, it will be known by the holy spirit who the priest is, then what will Elijah do? Surely even those brought near and those pushed away by force would be made known by that same holy spirit?
To this it seems clear and correct, according to our way which we stated above, that first there will be a gathering of the nobles of the people without a prophet, and we shall offer sacrifices on the altar of Yahweh, and afterward Gog will come, and afterward Elijah will come, at the end and completion of the redemption, before the great and terrible day comes. And therefore there will be a great necessity for the law given to Moses at Sinai mentioned above; for when the altar is built before Elijah comes, we would not know how we are to make a sweet savour to Yahweh, since we would have to merit a prophet who would inform us who is fit to be priest to offer a sacrifice to Yahweh. And when there is no sacrifice to atone and to find favour before Yahweh, the light of prophecy, which comes after the sacrifice, will not appear; as it was in the First Sanctuary, when on the offering of the sacrifice the cloud filled the holy place, and so it was in the days of the consecration of the Tabernacle in the wilderness; and as I brought above from the Sifre, that we are not to wait for a prophet but only to seek Zion, and afterward a prophet will come; and as with Manoah, where He wrought wonders through the sacrifice. And if we then wait upon the purity of the priests through a prophet, there will be no sacrifice, and if so the beginning of the redemption would be almost an impossibility, Heaven forbid; for there is no sacrifice without Elijah, on account of the priests, and no Elijah without a sacrifice. For this the Great in counsel set the healing remedy beforehand, informing us through the law given to Moses at Sinai that we are not to wait for Elijah for the sake of the purity of the priests; for all the priests will be in the presumption of their fitness in the future, and Elijah does not come to bring near or to push away; rather, everyone who traces his descent from his fathers under the name of priest, and no flaw is found in him, we follow the majority and the presumption, since there is no way to clarify it through the record of their genealogy. And Elijah comes only to bring near one who was absorbed. One in whom there was a trace of disqualification, and they pushed him away out of doubt, or pushed him away by force and by the strength of their hand, not according to law: as the sons of Zion did to a certain family; or the reverse, that it was fit to be disqualified out of doubt and its friends brought it near by force: in such cases as these Elijah will make the truth known, since it was not made fit according to the law of the Torah. But one who was made fit according to the law of the Torah, as when we relied on the presumptions and declared it fit, then even if in truth there is a trace of disqualification in it, Elijah will not push it away, because the law of the Torah declared him fit, and the act of a court done according to law stands forever. And Rabbi Judah added that even those who were brought near not according to law Elijah will not push away; surely everyone who is called by his name, by the name of priest from his fathers, without a clarified flaw, shall minister with his brethren the priests. And so in the words of Maimonides in his Commentary on the Mishnah mentioned; these are his words: "And the Sages say: he does not concern himself with genealogies; everyone called by his name; all will trace their descent to the truth and to the Torah, which is the father of all." End of his words. And this is understood only according to our way mentioned above: that whoever the law of the Torah permitted on the basis of majority and presumption is "called by his name" and "traces his descent to the truth," even though it could be against the truth. The Torah forbade the disqualified, and it declared fit by majority and presumption and the other statutes of our holy Torah. And now go and learn: if one who was brought near not according to law Elijah will not push away, how much more will one in whom no flaw at all is known remain in the presumption of his fitness.
- And if one should answer me from the words of the Talmud, chapter 2 of Ketubot, folio 23, where they dispute whether one may promote from heave-offering to lineage, and from this verse: "These sought their register of genealogy, and it was not found, and they were put out of the priesthood as polluted" (Ezra 4): to this I reply for two reasons. 1) That in the time of the Second Temple most of the priests had a written genealogy
