49
"And not even such," remarked a learned rabbi in whose presence I expressed this view.
In truth, Judaism as a nationality has a natural basis, which cannot, like a confession of faith, be supplanted by another. A Jew, by his descent, always belongs to Judaism, no matter whether he or his forefathers have become apostates. — This may appear paradoxical according to modern notions of religion. In practice, at least, I have found this view confirmed. The baptized Jew, too, remains a Jew, however much he may struggle against it. To-day scarcely any difference is any longer to be perceived between the enlightened and the baptized. My friend Armand L., whose grandparents had already had themselves baptized, takes a livelier interest than many a circumcised Jew in the weal and woe of his kinsmen, and he has kept the faith in the Jewish nationality more faithfully than our enlightened rabbis.
It is not belief, but the search after the knowledge of God, that is enjoined upon the Jew. That is a matter of conscience, for which one has to render account to no one but oneself, and indeed can render it to no other. — To a shallow rationalism, it is true, it is as easy as to the blind faith of the charcoal-burner to rattle off its creed. Knowledge, on the other hand, which grows up out of the innermost life of the mind and heart, develops onward with the individual and with mankind; it cannot be fixed once for all by articles of faith. — Upon the deep dogmatic basis of Judaism divergent views of life could develop; for creative Judaism itself all these views of life are but transient moments, which are modified according to inner and outer experiences, and often seem to turn into their very opposite, but in which, for all the variety of their development, the original type out of which they have grown is not
4