Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
82printed page
scan 96 of 434
Facsimile · scan 96 of 434
Scan of p. 82
English · AI translation, not yet checked

82

are ceaselessly at work, at every moment causing only tiny changes, yet after millennia have calmly and uniformly built up and eroded continents and mountains, deepened and filled seas. The volcanic theory is more melodramatic; it makes of Earth's history an enormous spectacle, and such a thing is always assured of the gallery's applause. The neptunian theory is less theatrical, but it is more convincing for the serious minds who are practiced in observing the ordinary processes of nature.

Among those who have to pass judgment on Jewish history in the past, present, and future, one now likewise finds representatives of the volcanic and neptunian theories. The former, the Vulcanists, attach importance only to the intermittent great acts of violence against the Jews. For them, the history of the Jewish people is exhausted in the history of Jewish catastrophes. For them, it proceeds from the destruction of the Temple to the massacres of the Crusades, from the expulsion from England and France to the banishment from Spain, from the slaughters of Chmielnicki to the bloody persecutions of the early 80s. The Neptunists, on the other hand — and to this class I count myself — do not ascribe the same importance to the catastrophes, however terrible they might be, and do not recognize them as the only, or even as the principal, forces that shape modern Jewish history. For us, the ordinary conditions that uniformly and permanently surround us are the influences that shape the destiny of the Jewish people. All peoples, even the most glorious and powerful, have in their past severe misfortunes, upheavals, civil wars, crushing defeats, which are sometimes so terrible