Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
73printed page
scan 87 of 434
Facsimile · scan 87 of 434
Scan of p. 73
English · AI translation, not yet checked

73

the demand once again arises to make a collective effort, to show oneself and the world how much vitality, hope for life, and will to live one still contains. And then we must face the fact that much of what still seemed alive, as long as no proof of life was demanded of it, is in fact dead.

Numerous Jews have also outwardly fallen away from Judaism. This process of crumbling away has never entirely ceased since the destruction of the Second Temple; in recent years it has become particularly brisk in the countries of the West. An incomparably larger number of Jews, however, have not yet become aware of their inner apostasy from Judaism, although this apostasy has in fact taken place. They considered themselves, and the world considered them, to be Jews, but they were Jews only out of habit, out of convenience, out of mental lethargy. Their Judaism did expose them to persecution, but partly they no longer had enough sense of honor to suffer under the persecution, and partly they felt themselves to be interesting victims, which is not an unpleasant state of mind. In hours of sentimental reverie, they believed authors like Disraeli, George Eliot, Alexander Dumas fils, who sketched a flattering picture of Judaism, its mission, its power, its glorious future, and they reveled in this dream, which had the beauty and the unreality of dreams. Their Judaism demanded no positive accomplishments of them. They smiled at the 613 commandments and prohibitions of the Shulchan Aruch. The community tax did not weigh heavily upon them. Often, only the Day of Atonement reminded them of the way to the synagogue. Nevertheless, they convinced themselves that they were good Jews because they loved Heine, were edified by Daniel Deronda, and would let nothing detract from the fame of Kugel and Schalet.