Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
67printed page
scan 81 of 434

67 foreigners are denied entry into the country. "Destitute aliens" is the respectable fig leaf for the word "Jew," which English statesmen, in their modesty as educated sons of the nineteenth century, found too naked. The England that has always taken pride in being the refuge of all the persecuted, the natural home of all the homeless, that in earlier centuries hospitably received Flemings and Huguenots, under Cromwell the Sephardim led by Manasseh ben Israel, under George III the French émigrés, at the time of the Holy Alliance Mazzini, after 1848 the refugees from all countries of Europe, and in our days the anarchists hunted and outlawed everywhere—this sacred asylum of humanity suddenly closes itself to one group of people: to Jews.

One seeks to gloss over this cruelty, which mocks all English traditions, with justifications. The foreign Jews are said to be a burden on English poor relief. They are said to take bread from English workers. These two reasons contradict each other and are mutually exclusive. If the Jews are beggars, then they do not take bread from English workers. If, on the other hand, they work so successfully that they take bread from English workers, then they are not beggars and cannot be a burden on poor relief. It has, moreover, been proven that both reasons are mere pretexts. The foreign Jews who land in England are not beggars, but diligent, ambitious workers who support themselves and often rise to relatively good circumstances. Those among them who temporarily require support receive it from their kinsmen and do not become a nuisance to the Christian English beyond the extent to which their contribution to the poor-tax entitles them. They also do not take from the English workers

5*