Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
66printed page
scan 80 of 434

66

antisemitism broke out because the Jews stood up for Dreyfus. The truth is that the Jews did not, in fact, stand up for Dreyfus, but that Christians did this; that the Jews, with the exception of two or three brave men, did not lift a finger in self-defense, although the case was used as a murder weapon against their honor. French antisemitism is not the consequence of the Dreyfus affair, but its cause. Had antisemitism not pre-existed, the suspicion of treason would most likely never have fallen upon Dreyfus, and in any case, neither would the guilt attributed to him have been generalized into a constitutional guilt of all Jews, nor would the effort to bring about a retrial have incited such furious popular passions. The Dreyfus affair has pulled back a veil and revealed previously hidden sentiments. It stands as a warning and a lesson to those Jews who still insist on believing in their final, unconditional acceptance into the national community of at least the most advanced states of the West. This gives it significance in the history of Judaism and even the serious educational value of a warning, an enlightenment, and a punishment, a value that makes it possible for us, with our ineradicable Jewish optimism, to exclaim even in the face of the Dreyfus affair: "Gam su letoba! This, too, is for the good!"

France is not the only land of freedom and enlightenment where the old specter of Jew-hatred roams in the full daylight of the most advanced civilization. In England, which I still praised enthusiastically last year, the government has already obtained the consent of the House of Lords for a bill that the destitute