Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
43printed page
scan 57 of 434

43

and official or social disfavor push the Jews down to the status of proletarians and professional paupers, without leaving them even the hope of raising themselves above this economic level through however great an individual or collective effort.

Those certain "practical" people, who deny themselves every "unfruitful reverie" and direct their endeavors to the most immediate, achievable things, are of the opinion that the abolition of legal restrictions would remedy the misery of the Jews in Eastern Europe. Galicia takes it upon itself to provide the critique of this opinion. And not Galicia alone. The remedy of legal emancipation has been tried in all states of the highest level of civilization. Let us see what the experiment teaches.

The Jews of Western Europe are subject to no legal restrictions. They may move and develop freely, just like their Christian compatriots. The economic consequences of this freedom of movement were indeed undoubtedly the most favorable. The Jewish racial characteristics of diligence, perseverance, sobriety, and thrift brought about the rapid decline of the Jewish proletariat, which in some countries would have disappeared completely if it were not nourished by Jewish immigration from the East. The emancipated Jews of the West attain moderate prosperity relatively quickly. In any case, the struggle for daily bread among them does not take on the horrific forms that are described in Russia, Romania, and Galicia. But among these Jews, the other Jewish distress arises: the moral one.

The Jew of the West has bread, but man does not live by bread alone. The Jew of the West hardly sees his body and life anymore