Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
323printed page
scan 337 of 434
Facsimile · scan 337 of 434
Scan of p. 323
English · AI translation, not yet checked

323

For as firmly as we are convinced that the immense majority of the Jewish people is Zionist at heart, we must nevertheless state that only a small minority has proven this through deeds.

But I go further. If the still improbable were to happen today, if Turkey, if the Great Powers were to say to us: "We open Palestine to you. We give you the right to administer your own internal affairs. Go and make yourselves at home in the old homeland," we could not accept this gift today at all, for the Jewish people is not yet prepared to form a self-contained economic body with all its organs and to fulfill all the economic, political, and moral tasks of a complete, class-structured, and self-sufficient people. The Galuth has made a chaos of us.

We are a loose heap of individuals without organic connection. We must first find this again. If we were to return to Palestine as human dust, not as a living, unified being, we would have to fear offering the world the spectacle of a pitiful anarchy, which our enemies would present as definitive proof that we Jews are completely unfit for creative work.

The Zionist enterprise must not suffer a collapse, for the damage that such an event would cause would be immeasurable. We may therefore only proceed step by step with the utmost caution and not take any task upon our shoulders before we are completely certain that we are strong enough to master it with ease. When we establish ourselves in Palestine, we must have the certainty that we can present ourselves with honor as a people with our own peasant and burgher classes, with our own police, administration of justice, tax administration, postal, construction, and educational systems. Before we these

21*