Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
318printed page
scan 332 of 434
Facsimile · scan 332 of 434
Scan of p. 318
English · AI translation, not yet checked

318

join us from these circles are the result of a strict selection. The Zionists of the West are neither ghetto social climbers nor publicity tigers, neither small profiteers nor speculators, neither vain followers nor parrots, as they can be where Zionism has already become a matter of the people and the majority; they are pure idealists, intrepid minority people and forceful natures of the toughest national grain. They are survivors in a harsh moral struggle for existence, in which the weaker ones have nationally perished. They are individualities whose hidden, inherited racial and folk substructure is exceptionally solid. But this is how the men must be constituted who are to lead the Zionist masses of the East on their paths and in their struggles.

Whoever might have read from these remarks that I already consider Western Jewry to have fallen away would not have understood me correctly. Certainly, it is on the path to falling away, and this will become final if no national renewal leads the strayed back to their tribe. The Vita nuova of Zionism, however, can save them for Judaism. It will certainly save them for Judaism once it is realized.

For let us be fair: we cannot demand of the average person, and thus also of the average Jew, either heroism or a rich visionary imagination. Both are exceptional gifts. The ordinary Jew today, in the countries where he has at least tolerable security of person and property, can imagine nothing other than his present circumstances. The law defines him as a German citizen. He has a fatherland. He has a people. He has a language. He has a culture. That all this is not his, he considers to be a