315 or other beautiful regions far away, in Turkey, where the peoples clash.”
It is unnecessary to continue this dialogue. It goes around in circles and gets nowhere, can get nowhere. Zionism is a matter of reason to the extent that, for instance, Euclidean three-dimensional geometry is. This too has postulates that cannot be proven. Zionism likewise has a postulate that is unattainable by rational proof because it resides in the sphere of feeling. The prerequisite of Zionism is Jewish feeling, pride in the history of the Jewish people, the desire for the historical continued development of the time-honored tribe. Where this prerequisite is lacking, Zionism cannot be defended and cannot be understood. It must seem senseless and unacceptable.
From this arises the method by which alone the Zionist idea can be promoted among assimilated Jews. It is no use arguing with mature Jews who have completely forgotten how to feel Jewish and who live with a consolidated asemitic or even antisemitic worldview. It is a waste of time and energy if we want to convince and convert these elements with rational arguments. What matters is to create Jewish feeling. For feelings, too, are created. They are an effect of upbringing, of early influences on the mind, but especially of example. Through these forces, one makes of the Jewish child Mortara a deeply faithful Catholic priest who feels Christian with Jewish sentimentality, and of the sons of immigrated Polish ghetto Jews, frizzy-haired Teutons who find that “a certain kernel of truth cannot be denied in antisemitism.” With these forces, one can make of
