Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
296printed page
scan 310 of 434

296 that it could ever be realized in practice. In this case, the Zionist would indeed have to make a choice. Since he could not possibly be a loyal patriot and a sincere Zionist at the same time, he would have to either renounce his Zionist ideal or else leave his fatherland in order to actually take up residence among his racial kinsmen. However, as long as there is no Jewish state with its own role in world politics that could conjure up a conflict of interest between it and the Zionist's fatherland, the Zionist is just as entitled to show his colors, to proclaim his aspirations, and to work toward the realization of his ideal as were the Philhellenes eighty years ago and the Armenophiles today, whose activities were and are indeed far more likely than Zionism to endanger the foreign policy of the respective fatherland.

Dishonest adversaries could still counter us with this: "The Zionist envisions a national future for the Jewish people and works toward it. If he is serious about this, he will also want to take part in that future. He is therefore thinking of leaving sooner or later. His sojourn in the fatherland is thus, by his own conception, merely a temporary one. Consequently, he is fundamentally a stranger, a temporary guest in the fatherland, and he cannot claim that trust which is only extended to the permanent citizens who have inextricably linked their existence with that of the fatherland and are absolutely unable to separate their future from that of their country."

To this we answer: "Year after year, hundreds of thousands and indeed hundreds of thousands more citizens of various European states emigrate from their fatherland in order to...