Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
16printed page
scan 30 of 434
Facsimile · scan 30 of 434
Scan of p. 16
English · AI translation, not yet checked

16

..., he will indeed remain in the position where he stands, but from his position, he will seek to help the pioneers who champion the Zionist idea with their entire personality, albeit perhaps hesitantly, secretly, avoiding every loud word.

He who no longer has enough Jewish feeling of solidarity for the thought of a national unification of the Jewish people to awaken in him a stir of approval, of sympathy, or even just of mere curiosity, but who nevertheless possesses the average measure of human charity, compassion, and benevolence, will at least appreciate Zionism for its side effect as a settlement enterprise, which seeks to prepare new homes for the poorest and most miserable among the Jews, those who have absolutely nothing to lose and can only ever gain from any change in their circumstances; and he will support Zionism, not because it seeks to found a Jewish state, but because it seeks to practice profound charity for poor, miserable people.

He who lacks not only all Jewish feeling, but even the most average human compassion; who takes no interest either as a Jew in the redemption of the Jews from political and social ostracism, or as a human being in the liberation of his fellow men from the bitterest distress—for him, the whole matter is of no concern. For him, Zionism does not exist; he will certainly not support it, but his cold-heartedness, his indifference, will always prevent him from attacking it.

Only one category of Jews will confront Zionism with hostility: the selfish, who fear for themselves some remote, evil consequence of the Zionist movement, who feel comfortable being despised and insulted and the