Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
276printed page
scan 290 of 434
Facsimile · scan 290 of 434
Scan of p. 276
English · AI translation, not yet checked

276

What are the colonists to do? Their tree plantations will not bring them any income for several more years, and they have no money to live on until they yield a profit. Their vineyards are already bearing grapes, but the grapes have no value in Palestine as table fruit, and they cannot make wine because the wine presses, presses, and cellars belong to the great benefactor who has closed them off, and they themselves have no money to buy the equipment and dig their own cellars.

But what is more: the money they believed they had received as wages for years is now, all at once, said to have been a mere advance, a loan that they are now supposed to repay.

So they not only stand suddenly as beggars in the midst of plantations that will only yield something in a few years and amidst vineyards from whose grapes they cannot make wine, they also have heavy debts which they cannot even think of repaying.

The great benefactor who has treated our colonists in this way has taken a terrible responsibility upon himself. May he bear it, and he alone. We, the Zionists, are not here to relieve him of it. What he has sinned against inexperienced, blindly trusting Jews, we Zionists cannot make right. That is not our calling.

We Zionists have always warned against such a colonization as has been practiced for the last twenty years. We have always taught and proclaimed the exact opposite of what has hitherto occurred in Palestine: no lawless infiltration, which delivers the immigrants without protection to the extortions and arbitrariness of the Turkish officials; no blind, haphazard colonization with people who